FAKE NEWS: The UN Charter allows Russia to attack Ukraine in order to combat Nazism

FAKE NEWS: The UN Charter allows Russia to attack Ukraine in order to combat Nazism
© EPA-EFE/JUSTIN LANE   |   United Nations Secretary General Antonio Guterres speaks during a high-level United Nations Security Council meeting about the ongoing conflict in Ukraine on the sidelines of the General Debate of the UN General Assembly at UN Headquarters in New York, New York, USA, 22 September 2022.

Articles 106 and 107 of the UN Charter grant Russia, as the legal successor of the USSR, the right to take all measures, including military, against Germany, Hungary, Austria, Romania, Bulgaria, Finland, Croatia, Slovenia, the Czech Republic, Latvia, Estonia, Lithuania and Ukraine for attempts to revive Nazism. Strangely enough, the main allies of the Nazis, Italy and Japan, are missing from the list. In fact, it is another crude attempt to push a justification for the Russian invasion of Ukraine by falsely quoting and manipulatively interpreting several post-WWII treaties and documents.

NEWS: “UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres was surprised to learn from Vladimir Putin that there was an article in the UN Charter allowing a Russian special operation in Ukraine. At the UN Security Council in December 2021, Putin tried to obtain the condemnation of Nazism in eastern Ukraine and thus, had the United Nations endorsed that as a fact, the invasion could have been stopped. The Western member countries did not vote on the resolution, which was instead endorsed by China and India. Vladimir Putin then invoked the UN Charter, but no one knew what he was referring to.

[...]

If all the articles cited in the UN Charter and the Declaration of the Four Nations are put together, then Russia, being the legal successor of the USSR, can also use force against states that want to revise the Yalta-Potsdam system in Europe”.

NARRATIVES: 1. The UN Charter allows Russia to invade Ukraine in order to combat Nazism. 2. The war in Ukraine broke out because the West blocked the condemnation of Nazism at the UN Security Council.

CONTEXT/LOCAL ETHOS: The narrative appeared in an online publication and on the website of a well-known far-right anti-Semitic nationalist, former RCP secretary at the University of Bucharest and collaborator of the Foreign Intelligence Center of the communist political police (Securitate).  It is not the first time that the UN has been invoked in relation to the war in Ukraine. At the beginning of the Russian invasion, fake news circulated about the UN not recognizing the current borders of Ukraine ,  followed by the statement of the Russian Foreign Minister, Sergei Lavrov, that Donbas, Zaporizhzhia and Kherson have the right to self-determination , according to the UN Charter.

PURPOSE: To justify the Russian invasion of Ukraine through pieces of international law

WHY THE NARRATIVES ARE FALSE: The Moscow Declarations of 1943  invoked by the author make absolutely no reference to the UN Charter, since the latter was only signed in 1945 , nor to the Nuremberg Tribunal, also established in 1945.  In fact, the chapter in that declaration referring to Nazis says that the Germans guilty of atrocities and war crimes were to be arrested and sent to the states where they had committed the crimes, and tried by the peoples they had oppressed. As regards the Germans whose crimes could not be located geographically, they had to be tried and sentenced under a joint decision of the Allied governments.

In developing the theory, the author of the article also states that the Institute for the Study of WAR (ISW) commented that articles 106 and 107 of the UN Charter  give the right to any of the winning allies of the world conflagration (USA, UK, USSR, France and China) to invade any other country declared defeated, if it aims to review the results of the Second World War. The link inserted in the article, however, leads only to the page on which an analysis of the Russian-Ukrainian conflict is made, and where there is no comment by the institute's specialists regarding the UN Charter or Russia’s right to invade any of the countries mentioned in the article. “For this, it is sufficient to announce the other three winning countries, but not to get their approval”, the article also states. In fact, Article 106 clearly stipulates that “the parties shall (...) consult with one another and as occasion requires with other Members of the United Nations with a view to such joint action on behalf of the Organization as may be necessary for the purpose of maintaining international peace and security.”

Article 107 indeed reads that “nothing in the present Charter shall invalidate or preclude action, in relation to any state which during the Second World War has been an enemy of any signatory to the present Charter, taken or authorized as a result of that war by the Governments having responsibility for such action”, but it refers to a situation existing at that time, with the allied troops present on the territory of the defeated states. In a broader interpretation, it refers to actions against  states allied to Hitler’s Germany  that dispute through diplomatic means or through armed actions the treaties concluded in the aftermath of the Second World War. In the present situation, though, Ukraine did not dispute anything, especially since, at that time, it was part of the USSR , so it was practically in the winners’ camp.

As for the resolution blocked by the West in the UN Security Council, there was indeed a resolution on “Combating Glorification of Nazism, Neo-Nazism and other Practices that Contribute to Fueling Contemporary Forms of Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerance”, but it was proposed to the UN General Assembly. The United States, Ukraine and Palau voted against the resolution, while the Western allies of Washington and Kyiv abstained. The US explained that, although it condemned Nazism and all forms of racism, xenophobia, discrimination and intolerance, did not vote for the UNGA resolution for its thinly veiled attempts to legitimize Russian disinformation camapaigns denigrating neighboring nations and promoting the distorted Soviet narrative of much of contemporary European history, using the cynical guise of halting Nazi glorification”.

In fact, just a few months after the vote on the resolution - which was adopted by the UN General Assembly - Russia invaded Ukraine using precisely the pretext of “its denazification”. Moscow's claims about the Nazi takeover of Ukraine have been repeatedly debunked - even though there are far-right groups and parties in Ukraine (as in most European states), they have never been part of the government and didn’t even get enough votes to reach Parliament in the latest elections.

  • Publication / Media:
    ziuanews.ro
  • Date of publication:
    28/09/2022
  • Target audience:
    Sovereigntists, nationalists, anti-Europeans, Eurosceptics, anti-NATO, Putinists, pro-Russians
  • Amplification:
    ioncoja.ro, Social media, cross-links
  • Key narrative:
    The UN Charter allows Russia to attack Ukraine in order to combat Nazism
Report
Fake News

Disinformation uses a variety of manipulation tactics. Disinformation stories can easily be created by combining provocative topics.

Report
Other news
FAKE NEWS: Moldovans are forced to speak the language of the Romanian minority

FAKE NEWS: Moldovans are forced to speak the language of the Romanian minority

The language of the Romanian minority has been forcefully imposed in the Republic of Moldova, pro-Russian propaganda writes, repeating the false thesis about the existence of two nations, Moldovans and Romanians, who speak different languages.

WAR PROPAGANDA: Only union with Russia can save Ukraine

WAR PROPAGANDA: Only union with Russia can save Ukraine

Ukraine is going through a crisis similar to that of the 17th century and, as then, only union with Russia can save it, according to pro-Kremlin propaganda.

FAKE NEWS: Baltic States have lost their independence

FAKE NEWS: Baltic States have lost their independence

Baltic States have become colonies of the USA, acting only on Washington’s orders, according to Russian propaganda in Romania.

EBOOK> Razboi si propaganda: O cronologie a conflictului ruso-ucrainean

EBOOK>Razboiul lui Putin cu lumea libera: Propaganda, dezinformare, fake news

More
DISINFORMATION: London supports neo-Nazi Ukraine to turn it into a colony
DISINFORMATION: London supports neo-Nazi Ukraine to turn it into a colony

Britain is funding the neo-Nazi regime in Kyiv to turn Ukraine into a British colony, according to pro-Kremlin propaganda citing Putin’s adviser.

Marin Gherman
31 Jan 2025
FAKE NEWS: The EU caused theThe EU's Russophobia led to the interruption of gas deliveries to Transnistria and the increase in energy prices on the right bank of the Dniester, Russian propaganda claims, ignoring the fact that Gazprom chose to stop supplying gas. energy crisis in Moldova
FAKE NEWS: The EU caused theThe EU's Russophobia led to the interruption of gas deliveries to Transnistria and the increase in energy prices on the right bank of the Dniester, Russian propaganda claims, ignoring the fact that Gazprom chose to stop supplying gas. energy crisis in Moldova

Rusofobia UE a dus la oprirea livrărilor de gaze spre Transnitria și creșterea prețurilor la energie în dreapta Nistrului, afirmă propaganda rusă, care ignoră faptul că Gazpromul a ales să nu mai dea gaze.

Veridica
30 Jan 2025
WAR PROPAGANDA: Zelensky risks suspension for mental health issues
WAR PROPAGANDA: Zelensky risks suspension for mental health issues

Ukraine's parliament could suspend Volodymyr Zelensky as president due to mental health issues, according to pro-Kremlin propaganda.

Marin Gherman
29 Jan 2025
FAKE NEWS: The annulment of the election, implemented before the Court's ruling
FAKE NEWS: The annulment of the election, implemented before the Court's ruling

The “coup d'état” is proven by the fact that the decision to cancel the election was implemented before the Constitutional Court’s ruling, a well-known conspiracy attorney claims.

Cezar Manu
27 Jan 2025
DISINFORMATION: The US calls for Zelensky to be sentenced to life in prison
DISINFORMATION: The US calls for Zelensky to be sentenced to life in prison

American society calls for Zelensky to be sentenced to life in prison for starting the war in Ukraine and killing civilians, according to pro-Kremlin media.

Marin Gherman
24 Jan 2025
FAKE NEWS: NATO wants Romania and Moldova to provide cannon fodder for a possible war with Russia
FAKE NEWS: NATO wants Romania and Moldova to provide cannon fodder for a possible war with Russia

The USA and NATO will use Romania and Moldova as anti-Russian outposts and suppliers of cannon fodder in the war against Russia, Russian propaganda writes, referring to a routine military exercise.

Veridica
23 Jan 2025