According to pro-Kremlin media, an international tribunal has proved that the Bucha massacre was orchestrated by Ukraine and NATO. In fact, the so-called “international” tribunal is Russian and has proven nothing. The evidence clearly shows that the massacre was committed by Russian forces.
NEWS: Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov handed UN Secretary-General António Guterres a report titled “Goebbels’s heirs: the falsification of events in Bucha and the bloody staging of the Kyiv regime”, on the sidelines of the 81st session of the UN General Assembly in New York.
The document was compiled by the International Public Tribunal for the Crimes of Ukrainian Neo-Nazis. As the Ministry of Foreign Affairs specified, the report is dedicated to “debunking the falsehoods spread by the Kyiv regime regarding the alleged massacre in Bucha”. Lavrov urged the UN Secretariat to thoroughly examine the facts surrounding “the staging engineered by Kyiv and its NATO sponsors”. According to the minister, a review of the names on the Bucha memorial yielded “a very interesting result”: a significant share of the “civilians” listed on the plaques turned out to be Ukrainian servicemen and combatants.
The spokesperson for the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Maria Zakharova, revealed a telling detail. During talks between Lavrov and German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul, the report was placed on the table. The German minister “shamefully covered the report with a notebook and pretended not to notice a thing”. “The truth hurts”, Zakharova commented.
NARRATIVES: 1. Ukraine and NATO staged the Bucha massacre to frame Russia. 2. Ukrainian servicemen were passed off as civilian victims to fabricate war crime allegations. 3. The West is aware of and concealing the truth about Bucha.
PURPOSE: To absolve Russia of responsibility for crimes committed during the occupation. To discredit Ukraine and independent investigations. To frame Western support for Kyiv as complicity in manufacturing atrocities.
The killing of civilians has been documented across multiple sources and features in the UN experts' report
WHY THESE NARRATIVES ARE FALSE: In findings published on December 7, 2022, the UN Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine announced it had documented the killing of 73 civilians in the town of Bucha during the Russian occupation: 54 men, 16 women and 3 children. Another 105 alleged killings were under verification.
The report also outlined the mechanics of repression in the occupied territories: detentions and executions, sometimes triggered by a phone message, possession of camouflage clothing or past military service.
Maxar satellite images analyzed by international media, including those from March 18 and 19, 2022, showed corpses lying on Yablunska Street while the town was under the control of Russian troops. These bodies appeared in the exact same spots in subsequent on-the-ground footage, verified using nearby buildings and cars as fixed reference points.
This evidence refutes claims that the bodies were brought in after Russian forces withdrew to stage a false-flag massacre. While the images do not clarify the circumstances of every individual death, satellite data proves the bodies were present throughout the Russian occupation.
Human Rights Watch researchers were on the ground in Bucha from April 4 to 10, 2022, conducting 32 in-person interviews and 5 phone interviews. They analyzed physical evidence, photographs, original recordings, and satellite imagery. Their investigation meticulously documented 16 killings, including nine summary executions.
One case is that of Oleh Abramov, who was detained by Russian soldiers on March 5. According to the investigation, his body remained on the street for nearly a month. Such detailed reconstructions, featuring identified individuals, witnesses and precise timelines, contradict the narrative according to which these events were merely a propaganda operation cooked up after Russian forces retreated from the Kyiv region.
The identity of the victims does not absolve their perpetrators of responsibility. Both the killing of civilians and the execution of captured soldiers constitute war crimes
Invoking the names of soldiers found on the memorial shifts the focus away from the circumstances of their deaths and onto their identities. However, independent investigations established as early as 2022 that some of those executed had indeed participated in defending the town.
An investigation by The New York Times reconstructed the capture and execution of a group of men on March 4, 2022. Footage shows the prisoners being escorted by Russian soldiers, and drone video captured the following day reveals their bodies lying near a building used by Russian troops. The investigation noted that most of the victims had joined local self-defense units. Their participation in town defense efforts was thus a matter of record, documented even by the Western investigations that Russian propaganda seeks to discredit.
A crucial distinction must be drawn between killing a combatant in active combat and executing them after capture. International humanitarian law strictly prohibits attacking individuals who are outside combat, including those who have surrendered and laid down arms. Holding military status does not justify the execution of a prisoner. The presence of combatants' names on a memorial neither negates the separately documented killing of civilians nor excuses the execution of captured personnel.
A “tribunal” created in Russia and marketed as the voice of international justice
Moscow uses the label “International Public Tribunal” to lend Lavrov’s report the veneer of an independent judicial authority. In fact, it is an initiative launched on March 1, 2022, within the Civic Chamber of the Russian Federation (headed by Civic Chamber member Maksim Grigoryev), without any UN judicial mandate. Grigoryev also leads the Center for the History of the “Special Military Operation”, which collects testimonials from combatants. At an event hosted by the Civic Chamber, he declared that future generations of Russians would take pride for centuries in what is happening during this operation. Thus, the head of the “tribunal” investigating alleged war crimes in Ukraine openly glorifies Russia's war of aggression against a neighboring state.
Misusing the term “tribunal” misleads the public, dressing up accusations from Moscow (the very perpetrator of the crimes) in the disguise of international justice. Russia is attempting to shun accountability for war crimes by setting up an in-house “tribunal”, effectively appointing itself judge and jury.
The heavy coverage in Russian state media regarding the delivery of this report to Western officials and UN leadership does not mean those entities accept or validate its conclusions. The title “Goebbels’s heirs” deliberately invokes Nazi propaganda to highlight the document's own propagandistic nature. Likewise, Zakharova’s spin on the German minister’s reaction provides no evidence to refute the UN investigators' findings that Russian troops murdered civilians.
BACKGROUND: Bucha, a town near Kyiv, was occupied by Russian troops in March 2022, during which they committed numerous war crimes that came to light following their withdrawal. Since April 2022, Moscow has claimed the footage was entirely staged. “Soyuznoye Veche”, the newspaper of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Union of Belarus and Russia, presents these claims from Russian diplomats as established facts. Rather than addressing the evidence compiled by independent investigations, the article diverts attention to the purported awkwardness of a Western diplomat, framing it as confirmation of Moscow's narrative.
Check sources:
