In Bulgaria, the EU dream is gradually turning into a RU nightmare

In Bulgaria, the EU dream is gradually turning into a RU nightmare
© EPA-EFE/VASSIL DONEV   |   People take part in the Pride Parade in downtown Sofia, Bulgaria, 22 June 2024.

Bulgaria showed signs of further democratic regression after its Parliament passed a law, on August 7, which prohibits “propaganda” for “ideas and views connected to nontraditional sexual orientation or to gender-identifying different from the biological” in schools. This development has been followed by calls for a “foreign agents” law to further limit liberal and critical voices.

Momentum for Bulgaria’s far-right

The engine behind the two laws was the far-right pro-Russian Revival party, but they gained traction after winning support from some of the pro-Western parties that made an unexpected populist gamble.

The anti-LGBTQ+ law was voted by MPs from Revival and the Bulgarian Socialist Party, but also by the pro-EU GERB, which is the biggest party in the parliament, the Movement for Rights and Freedoms, and the increasingly nationalist There’s Such a People who even demanded that access to scientific resources connected to the topic of gender must be limited.

Support also came from independent MP’s previously associated with the now dissolved parliamentary group of Greatness – a party which would probably be remembered as political one-hit wonders and made its way to the parliament in June. Greatness is the political extension of a circle of shareholders of the tourist site called Historical Park near Varna, made to glorify Bulgaria’s history. The whole project has been repeatedly investigated as a Ponzi and has been connected with paramilitary training. On August 12, the National Security State Agency issued a report in which it described the Historical Park site as a financial fraud costing 35 million euro and without much specifics, mentioned that business and party founder Ivelin Mihaylov had connections with Russia’s Night Wolves.

While members of reformist duo We Continue the Change or Democratic Bulgaria voted against or abstained, the alliance was criticized for not being more active on the topic.

The turn of events is an unprecedented validation for Revival, a party which, from a marginal presence, gained wider support after it adopted anti-vaxx positions during the COVID-19 pandemic, entered the parliament, remained hardline over Ukraine and is increasingly aggressive in its vocabulary and campaign tactics.

After the adoption of the anti-LGBTQ+ amendment, Revival started openly talking about passing another Russian-styled law: the “foreign agents” bill which would see sanctions against anyone working with funds outside of the state or the EU. Attempts for such a law were made in 2022. Internationally, it most recently made headlines around the adoption in Georgia in late 2023, followed by protests.

The development unleashed widespread outrage, with protests against the amendment taking place in Sofia and Varna, as well as in Berlin, London and the Hague and organised by local immigrant communities.

Slogans such as the ironic “Spasibo, GERB” and the alarmist “Bulgaria is not Russia” were among the popular statements during the demonstrations in Sofia, sometimes held in close proximity to crowds gathering in favor of the law.

In recent days, teachers and academics who opposed the LGBTQ law have been harassed and threatened online by Telegram and Facebook groups connected to Revival, some motivating parents to take actions against the teachers in opposition.

The conservative reinvention of GERB

While GERB’s support of the LGBTQ+ law and newfound allegiance to Revival came as a surprise, this move is not exactly unexpected and is more representative for the complex parliament dynamics rather than a sudden geopolitical shift.

GERB are prone to risky populist moves for quick gains: between 2017-2021, Borissov governed in a coalition with now defunct far-right alliance United Patriots and in 2020, amid a wave of anti-establishment protests, GERB imposed a veto on the EU ascension of North Macedonia, reigniting historical debates and poisoning the diplomatic relations between the two countries for the near future.

In 2023 GERB seemed to move towards a firmly pro-EU stance, in line with their archrivals/former coalition partners from We Continue the Change and Democratic Bulgaria. However, as that alliance crumbled, GERB turned to its most conservative based, in what seems to be an attempt to ride the right wing surge in the country.

Through the disputes around the LGBTQ+amendment, GERB and Revival essentially tested a potential parliament majority as after the coming elections in October, GERB will have almost no good moves for a coalition: all bridges back to We Continue the Change and Democratic Bulgaria seems to be burned, while loyal partners Movement for Rights and Freedoms have split in two camps around the sudden conflict between party’s key leaders.

As other parties appear disoriented and marred in internal conflicts, for Revival and GERB the controversial move also kick-started their current campaigns and outlines a strong narrative amid the expected low voter interest (34.41 per cent voted in June 2024, compared to 50.61 per cent in April 2021 at the beginning of Bulgaria’s logjam).

Weary Bulgarians will head to the polls for new general elections – the seventh in just three years – on October 27.

However, the current developments are maybe a bit too much for Bulgaria’s predominantly, even if divided, pro-EU society. According to a survey by Alpha Research, made available on August 20 and done in collaboration with Sofia’s Human and Social Studies Foundation, there’s a rising number in people seeing Bulgaria potentially distancing itself or leaving the EU as a strongly negative scenario: 30.9 per cent in 2024 in comparison to 22.2 per cent in 2023.

“There’s a point in which the anti-liberal propaganda is becoming counterproductive for its own goals”, the survey concludes.

Other opinions
The Russian Dream “reunification plan” is a dream scenario for Russia

The Russian Dream “reunification plan” is a dream scenario for Russia

Georgia’s de facto leader Bidzina Ivanishvili wants Tbilisi to apologize for the 2008 war Russia waged against his country. In return he promises Georgia’s reunification under a scenario that would benefit Moscow.

EBOOK> Razboi si propaganda: O cronologie a conflictului ruso-ucrainean

EBOOK>Razboiul lui Putin cu lumea libera: Propaganda, dezinformare, fake news

The Economy of Death: Russia’s Military Expansion and Its Human Cost

The Economy of Death: Russia’s Military Expansion and Its Human Cost

Russia needs recruits to cover its heavy losses on the Ukrainian front. To avoid an unpopular mobilization, Moscow has created an economy of death, in which Russians stake their lives for money.

Kaczyński and his party in big trouble

Kaczyński and his party in big trouble

Law and Justice (PiS) is getting into more and more trouble – the party is shaken by scandals connected to its eight-year rule, financial problems, and increasingly strong internal conflicts.

More
Why is Serbia seemingly trying to court Estonia?
Why is Serbia seemingly trying to court Estonia?

As Serbia’s relationship with the EU are tensed by a range of issue, including support for Russia, Belgrade is opening towards Estonia, one of Europe’s harshest Russia critics.

Moscow's “red lines”: Putin's imagination vs. the hard reality of war
Moscow's “red lines”: Putin's imagination vs. the hard reality of war

Russia is threatening to unleash a nuclear Armageddon if certain “red lines” are crossed to prevent the delivery of weapons to Ukraine. However, the threats do not seem as serious as Putin wants everyone to believe.

Russia both criticizes and fuels Romania’s neo-Nazism
Russia both criticizes and fuels Romania’s neo-Nazism

A recent report published by the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs criticizes Romania’s “neo-Nazism” and describes as state policies the actions of certain pro-Russian extremists, including figures praised and cited by Kremlin propaganda.

Cezar Manu
25 Sep 2024
Between Profit and Principle: The Dilemma of Foreign Businesses in Russia
Between Profit and Principle: The Dilemma of Foreign Businesses in Russia

Sanctions and public pressure generated by the invasion of Ukraine forced many Western companies to leave the Russian market. However, there are enough investors who chose to stay, drawn by its potential.

Belarusian ultras opposing Lukashenko are now fighting for Ukraine
Belarusian ultras opposing Lukashenko are now fighting for Ukraine

Ultras have been at odds with Lukashenko over his clampdown on national identity, Covid policies and rigging of elections. Fleeing persecution at home, some found their way to the frontlines of the war in Ukraine.

Are the EU and China heading for a trade war?
Are the EU and China heading for a trade war?

The first "shots" have already been fired: the EU is preparing taxes for the Chinese electric ve-hicles, and Beijing is investigating European subsidies for some products exported to China.