Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube LinkedIn

Fake News

FAKE NEWS: Fewer and fewer UN countries support Ukraine on the Crimean issue

Crimeea
©  |  
False
True

NEWS: Ukraine no longer enjoys UN’s support on the Crimean issue

“Fewer and fewer members of the UN support the resolutions promoted by Ukraine against Crimea.”

According to the "Novyi deni" correspondent, this is what the DNR citizen, Russian historian and political scientist Vladimir Kornilov told Russia 1. He claims that as the years go by, Kiev gets more active in promoting the issue of Crimea, but the Kiev regime does not enjoy support. The new anti-Crimea resolution was voted by the smallest number of UN states since 2014. "Today, Ukraine, just like every year, has traditionally brought to the fore its resolution condemning Russia's militarization of Crimea. I see that every year, these resolutions against Crimea are voted on by fewer and fewer states and individuals. I remind you that in 2014 the Ukrainian resolution was voted by 100 states, then by 70 […] and by only 62 today. Fewer and fewer states every year ", Vladimir Kornilov said."

NARRATIVES: 1. Ukraine no longer enjoys UN support for the Crimean issue. 2. The issue of the status of Crimea is especially promoted by the "Kiev regime". 3. Ukraine's international initiatives are anti-Crimean.

LOCAL CONTEXT / ETHOS: Since 2014, the international community has been condemning Russia's annexation of Crimea. Ukraine has initiated a series of UN General Assembly resolutions, which have been voted on by member states, and the EU, the USA, etc. have introduced sanctions against Russia for violations of international law. On the other hand, Moscow claims that it was guided by historical and international law, accepting the voluntary union of Crimea with Russia, as a result of a referendum. The referendum, however, was not recognized by the international community and took place in the context in which the peninsula had already been occupied by "the little green men". In recent years, Russia has tried to keep the Crimean issue away from international debates, but Ukraine has constantly brought it back to the international agenda. The Kremlin is trying to prove to the people of the peninsula, as well as Ukrainian and Russian readers, that the international community has begun to come to terms with the thought that Crimea will be a part of Russia forever, and Ukraine is no longer supported from outside.

PURPOSE: To disseminate news about the "Kiev regime", which is no longer able to convince the international community that it is necessary to maintain sanctions against Russia. It is also an attempt to show that UN resolutions are directed against the people of Crimea, which could cause the local population to distance itself even more from the Ukrainian state. The above news is commented by a political scientist who is a citizen of the self-proclaimed Donetsk People's Republic (DNR) (a secondary purpose being that of planting in the collective mind the notion of "DNR citizen") and signed by a Crimean journalist.

WHY THE NARRATIVES ARE FALSE: The information about the decreasing number of UN states that support Ukraine on the Crimean issue is not true. Every year, the Crimea-related resolutions are on different issues: in the last 2 years, the militarization of the peninsula, the location of nuclear weapons and the security threats for the states in the region have been increasingly tackled. The narrative in question presents the reader with a distorted reality based on an unrepresentative comparison and a false generalization - "Ukraine no longer enjoys UN support on the issue of Crimea." The impression is created that the same resolution is put to the vote every year. In fact, the text of the resolutions has become increasingly harsh on Russia since 2014. In reality, the resolution was voted not by 62, but by 63 states. If in 2019, 19 states voted against the resolution alongside Russia, then in 2020 - only 17 did so (Armenia, Belarus, Cambodia, China, Cuba, North Korea, Iran, Syria, etc.). There’s been a decrease in the number of Russian supporters in the Crimean issue, a situation intentionally "unnoticed" by the Russian and pro-Russian press. The narratives of the Russian press include a comparison of votes per year on different resolutions and different issues: resolutions condemning the annexation, resolutions on the issue of human rights, on the repression of the Tatar population, the militarization of Crimea or the persecution of journalists. The comparison is intentionally presented in such a way as to show that these UN processes mean a possible diplomatic recognition of the occupation of the peninsula in the future. The 2020 resolution cites another 7 UN documents, which were violated by Russia by occupying Ukrainian territory. The Russian press is ignoring some new elements of the UN 2020 resolution, such as urging Russia not to expand the Crimean militarization project, including by retaining nuclear weapons, which poses a threat to regional and global security. The resolution is not directed against the people of Crimea but aims to condemn the militarization of the peninsula and to prevent future human rights violations.

GRAIN OF TRUTH: The UN resolution of December 2020, stating that Crimea is temporarily occupied in violation of international law, was endorsed by 63 states. It’s true, though, that the international community seems a bit tired of this issue and the number of those strongly supporting Ukraine’s stand has decreased, but the figures depend primarily on the content of the resolutions. The harder they’ve become on Russia, the larger the number of states becoming neutral has grown.  OFFICIAL REACTIONS: After the adoption of the resolution, the representative of Ukraine at the UN, Sehii Kisliția, stated that “Russia is losing international support, though the resolution was voted by 2 states less than last year. We do not have less support, but what matters is not the number, it’s the content of the document.”

 

 

Tags: Ukraine

  • Publication / Media:
    newdaynews.ru
  • Date of publication:
    08/12/2020
  • Language / Target audience:
    Readers in Crimea, Russia and ex-soviet countries
  • Amplification:
    TASS, svpressa.ru, news-front.info, Russian media, pro-Russian media in Ukraine, Crimea news portals, the social media
  • Political affiliation:
    The Kremlin
  • Key narrative:
    The international community no longer supports Ukraine on the Crimean issue
Other articles
FAKE NEWS: Moldovans are no longer allowed in the EU

FAKE NEWS: Moldovans are no longer allowed in the EU

The European Union has closed its borders to the citizens of the Republic of Moldova, according to a publication close to the Socialists that seeks to mislead the public based on a simple technical measure of the EU Council, which recommended the Member States to impose certain travel restrictions, against the background of the pandemic.

FAKE NEWS: Romania – on the brink of war due to anti-COVID restrictions

FAKE NEWS: Romania – on the brink of war due to anti-COVID restrictions

Much like the rest of Europe, Romania will be drawn into a war due to restrictions imposed to curb the coronavirus pandemic, reads a narrative promoted by the Kremlin’s mouthpiece, Sputnik.

FAKE NEWS: Facebook is censoring Igor Dodon

FAKE NEWS: Facebook is censoring Igor Dodon

The former president of the Republic of Moldova, Igor Dodon, considers that he lost the presidential elections last autumn also due to Facebook, which allegedly deleted the likes he received and blocked the accounts of his party members. Ironically, the allegations were made in a video streamed on Facebook. Dodon thus joined a wave of attacks against these networks, launched in several countries, from Russia and EU member states to the United States.

Marin Gherman

01 Jan 2021
Marin Gherman

4 minutes read
FAKE NEWS: The EU Association Agreement is detrimental to Moldova
FAKE NEWS: The EU Association Agreement is detrimental to Moldova

The EU Association Agreement did not bring any gains to Moldova, which lost the Russian market without being able to export to the EU, according to a false narrative published in the Russian media.

Cornel Ciobanu
Cornel Ciobanu
29 Nov 2021
FAKE NEWS: A dictatorship has been established in Moldova and it will destroy the country
FAKE NEWS: A dictatorship has been established in Moldova and it will destroy the country

The West is sending its agents to Moldova to destroy it, and the current administration can only preserve its power by means of a dictatorship. The narratives are promoted in response to the appointment of two independent experts in the commission charged with evaluating the activity of the suspended prosecutor general, Alexandr Stoianoglo.

Mariana Vasilache
Mariana Vasilache
26 Nov 2021
FAKE NEWS: “Romania, a bridgehead for a NATO-Russia war”
FAKE NEWS: “Romania, a bridgehead for a NATO-Russia war”

Romania will be drawn into a NATO-Russia war in Ukraine and Romanians will be cannon fodder in the front line, according to a false narrative carried recently by the media in Bucharest.

Mădălin Necșuțu
Mădălin Necșuțu
24 Nov 2021
FAKE NEWS: Schools with Russian-language teaching are being closed down in the Republic of Moldova
FAKE NEWS: Schools with Russian-language teaching are being closed down in the Republic of Moldova

The closing down of a grammar school for 51 pupils gave rise to a false narrative claiming that “Russian-language schools are being closed down in the Republic of Moldova”.

Cornel Ciobanu
Cornel Ciobanu
22 Nov 2021