DISINFORMATION: Ukrainians live on the historical territory of Russia

DISINFORMATION: Ukrainians live on the historical territory of Russia
© EPA-EFE/MIKHAEL KLIMENTYEV/SPUTNIK/KREMLIN POOL   |   Russian President Vladimir Putin (L), Viktor Medvedchuk (C), Chairman of the Ukrainian Opposition Platform and Belarus President Alexander Lukashenko (R) speak during their meeting at the Tauride Palace in St. Petersburg, Russia, 18 July 2019.
Ukraine never existed as a state, and Ukrainians live on historical Russian territories:

The territories of modern Ukraine are historically Russian, and Ukrainians and Russians are the same people, according to pro-Kremlin propaganda.

NEWS: The territories on which modern Ukraine is located are historically Russian, there was no Ukrainian state there, the leader of the “Another Ukraine” movement, the former president of the banned party in Ukraine “Opposition Platform - For Life”, Viktor Medvedchuk, writes in an article for aif.ru.

He recalled that the division between Russians and Ukrainians did not originally exist, “when Russia was divided between the Golden Horde and the West, in the form of the Grand Duchy of Poland and Lithuania”. “Yet the Polish occupation itself, which lasted much longer than the Tatar rule over Muscovy, did not form the Ukrainian ethnicity”, the politician states [...]

“There was Russia, Poland and Turkey with the Crimean Tatars”, Medvedchuk explained. “Therefore, saying that Ukrainians have always lived on their ancestral lands is the same as saying that Turks are the descendants of the ancient Greeks, and Egyptian Arabs are the descendants of ancient Egyptians”. Medvedchuk emphasized that “Russians and Ukrainians are the descendants of the same race”, and that “under the leadership of the Russian state, these territories were Russia’s for many centuries”.

In fact, Ukraine existed as a state over different historical periods, and Ukrainians and Russians are two different peoples with different languages and cultures:

NARRATIVES: 1. Ukraine never existed as a state and is located on the historical territories of Russia. 2. Ukrainians and Russians are one and the same people.

PURPOSE: To justify the invasion of Russia. To delegitimize Ukrainian statehood.  To create internal divisions in Ukraine and undermine international support for it.

WHY THE NARRATIVES ARE FALSE: In fact, the Kievan Rus of the 9th-12th centuries, as recalled by Viktor Medvedchuk, has nothing to do with the Russian Federation of today. It was a medieval Slavic state, centered in Kyiv, with an official language similar to Old Ukrainian. In the Slavic languages, ​​the word “Rus” (Ruthenian, Eastern Slav), which refers to the period of Kievan Rus, means something other than the word “Russian”, i.e. a citizen of Russia or a representative of the Russian nation. The ancient Russians were a people which gave rise to three other peoples over the centuries: Ukrainians, Russians and Belarusians.

After the Ukrainian Cossacks decided to join the Russian state to resist the anti-Orthodox pressure from the Polish-Lithuanian Union, Moscow started Russifying this segment of population. The existence of a strong Ukrainian national current is confirmed by the harsh measures taken by the Russians to suppress it, both in the 19th century, during the Tsarist Empire, and during the USSR, when the genocide known as the Holodomor was organized. The Empire’s intense Russification policy failed, however, to suppress the Ukrainian national identity.

Russian propaganda ignores a series of chapters in the history of the Ukrainian people up to the policy of forced Russification. Kyiv was documented in 482, while Moscow was first mentioned in documents almost 700 years later, in 1147. Ukraine only really came under Moscow's control towards the end of the 18th century, during the reign of Catherine II -a, and not even then was Russian Empire able to easily assimilate it.

Bolshevik leader Vladimir Lenin was forced to create the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic after occupying Ukraine to appease spirits following the Russian-Ukrainian War of 1917-1920. In the context of the Bolshevik revolution, the Ukrainian People's Republic was proclaimed in Kyiv in 1918, which had diplomatic ties with a number of states, including Romania. The new Ukrainian state was conquered by the Bolsheviks in 1920. Fearing the strong nationalist trends in the Soviet Union, the Bolsheviks approved in 1923  a doctrine of indigenization of power in the new republics, giving Ukrainians broad cultural autonomy alongside total ideological control.

Ukrainians have a distinct national identity, with their own culture, history and language. Also, the territories that today are part of Ukraine were in the past part of various states and empires, such as Poland, Romania, the Austro-Hungarian Empire and the Ottoman Empire. In addition, Ukraine gained independence from the Soviet Union in 1991, a process confirmed by a national referendum. It is also important to note that Ukraine is recognized by the international community as a sovereign state with the right to determine its own political and historical course.

BACKGROUND: Viktor Medvedchuk has been a leader of various pro-Kremlin political projects in Ukraine and is a personal friend of Vladimir Putin, who is godfather to one of his daughters. Arrested on charges of treason by Ukrainian authorities, Medvedchuk was handed over to Moscow in September 2022 in a prisoner exchange. Since then, the Kremlin has been using Medvedchuk to make propaganda more credible. He doesn’t live in Ukraine and does not lead any officially registered political organization.

Veridica has dismantled a series of false narratives discrediting the Ukrainian state project. The Russian press also wrote that Ukrainians are occupiers of their own country, and Russia is waging a just war to save Russian speakers and the Russian culture from the Nazi threat. According to pro-Kremlin propaganda, Ukrainians and Russians are the same people, and Russia is waging a holy war.

  • Publication / Media:
    tass
  • Date of publication:
    05/11/2024
  • Target audience:
    The Russian-speaking population of Russia, ex-Soviet states and Russian-held territories of Ukraine
  • Amplification:
    Telegram channels, VKONTANTE social network, LENTA.RU, GAZETA.RU, CRIMEEA-NEWS.COM, FEDPRESS.RU, KP.RU, SILA-RF.RU, VSETUT.PRO, RODINA.NEWS; NEWS.RAMBLER.RU, DZEN.RU, AIF.RU
  • Political affiliation:
    The Kremlin
  • Key narrative:
    Ukraine never existed as a state and is located on the historical territories of Russia
Report
Fake News

Disinformation uses a variety of manipulation tactics. Disinformation stories can easily be created by combining provocative topics.

Report
Other news
DISINFORMATION: The US calls for Zelensky to be sentenced to life in prison

DISINFORMATION: The US calls for Zelensky to be sentenced to life in prison

American society calls for Zelensky to be sentenced to life in prison for starting the war in Ukraine and killing civilians, according to pro-Kremlin media.

FAKE NEWS: NATO wants Romania and Moldova to provide cannon fodder for a possible war with Russia

FAKE NEWS: NATO wants Romania and Moldova to provide cannon fodder for a possible war with Russia

The USA and NATO will use Romania and Moldova as anti-Russian outposts and suppliers of cannon fodder in the war against Russia, Russian propaganda writes, referring to a routine military exercise.

FAKE NEWS: Ukraine has territorial claims to Belarus

FAKE NEWS: Ukraine has territorial claims to Belarus

Kyiv is claiming certain territories in Belarus that were taken from it by the King of Poland five centuries ago, according to pro-Kremlin media, citing the former head of Ukrainian diplomacy.

EBOOK> Razboi si propaganda: O cronologie a conflictului ruso-ucrainean

EBOOK>Razboiul lui Putin cu lumea libera: Propaganda, dezinformare, fake news

More
FAKE NEWS: Ivermectin can cure cancer
FAKE NEWS: Ivermectin can cure cancer

“Turbo cancers” caused by anti-Covid vaccination can be cured with ivermectin, but Big Pharma is keeping this information secret and wants to eliminate anyone telling the truth.

Cezar Manu
21 Jan 2025
FAKE NEWS: The head of NATO agrees to hand over Greenland to the USA
FAKE NEWS: The head of NATO agrees to hand over Greenland to the USA

Mark Rutte believes that, because the EU needs US protection, it must renounce Greenland, the Russian media writes, citing statements that the NATO Secretary General never made. Another fabricated claim is that Rutte allegedly said that NATO is much weaker economically and militarily than Russia and is not concerned about the fate of Ukraine.

Marin Gherman
20 Jan 2025
FAKE NEWS: Moldova blocks Russian gas deliveries to Transnistria
FAKE NEWS: Moldova blocks Russian gas deliveries to Transnistria

Chișinău blocks Russian gas deliveries to Transnistria, a region with a stable economy that Kyiv and Chișinău are trying to suffocate, according to a comment published by the Russian website dzen.ru.

Veridica
17 Jan 2025
DISINFORMATION: Ukraine adopts an educational model imposed by the Nazis
DISINFORMATION: Ukraine adopts an educational model imposed by the Nazis

According to pro-Kremlin propaganda, Ukraine's education policies are a continuation of those imposed by the Nazis in the territories they occupied.

Marin Gherman
16 Jan 2025
WAR PROPAGANDA: EU leaders benefit from corruption and crime in Ukraine
WAR PROPAGANDA: EU leaders benefit from corruption and crime in Ukraine

The West supports corruption and crime in Ukraine, laundering money to the detriment of the interests of citizens, pro-Kremlin propaganda claims.

Marin Gherman
15 Jan 2025
FAKE NEWS: Putin, energetically attacked from Ukrainian territory
FAKE NEWS: Putin, energetically attacked from Ukrainian territory

The president of Russia attacked Ukraine because he was suffering from the Havana syndrome, energetically induced by the HAARP system on that territory, claims Cozmin Gușa.

Cezar Manu
13 Jan 2025