Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube LinkedIn

DISINFORMATION: UE is strongarming Romania to renounce its Constitution and sovereignty

Disinformation

Romania will have to renounce its Constitution and sovereignty, according to a new disinformation amplified by Senator Diana Șoșoacă and Sputnik. The source headlines a statement falsely attributed to the head of the European Commission’s Office in Romania.

NEWS: “The head of the European Commission’s Office claims Romania must renounce its own Constitution in order to abide by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU)”, stiripesurse.ro writes, publishing an interview Ramona Chiriac gave to news.ro. Both the title of the original interview, as well as the one published by stiripesurse.ro, also refer to Romania’s National Recovery and Resilience Plan (PNRR): “modifying PNRR entails going through the whole process all over again”, news.ro writes quoting Ramona Chiriac: “modifying PNRR is “not in the least” in Romania’s best interest, stiripesurse.ro headlines, mixing the reporter’s question with a single phrase uttered by Ramona Chiriac – “not in the least”.

The article published by stiripesurse.ro was also shared by Senator Diana Șoșoacă on her official Facebook page. The Senator writes, among other things, that the end-goal of PNRR is to “renounce sovereignty and make vaccination mandatory, eliminate private animal breeding and private property, shut down mines and skyrocket energy prices, brain drain, destroying the education and soon the destruction of the country and renaming it the Region of Romania, unless it is given a German or a Hungarian name”.

Sputnik.md refers to the post on “Diana Ivanovici Șoșoacă – oficial” page on Facebook, but presents the content as the “stake” of the European Commission’s plans for Romania”. The article in Sputnik focuses on the relation between the Constitutional Court and the CJEU: “Senator Diana Șoșoacă intervenes in the wake of the outrageous statements made by Ramona Chiriac, the head of the European Commission’s Office in Romania, who attacked the Constitutional Court and said European law prevails over national law.

“If anyone needed further proof of national treason, of renouncing Romania’s sovereignty, that vaccination is made mandatory and that representing us at EU level are traitors, Sorosists, globalists, turncoats and double-crossers, there you have it, the living proof of everything”, Șoșoacă writes on her Facebook page, sharing an article with Ramona Chiriac’s statements.

Reality

NARRATIVES: 1. The EU is strongarming Romania to renounce its own Constitution. 2. PNRR will lead to Romania losing its sovereignty. 3. Romania will be destroyed and turned in to a region. 4. Private property will be abolished, the education system will be destroyed, and the intellectual elites will move to other countries.

BACKGROUND: On December 21, 2021, the Court of Justice of the European Union issued a ruling reasserting the prevalence of European law over national legislation. More specifically, Romanian courts of law may hand out sentences that go against the Constitutional Court as long as they fall in line with European legislation. The Constitutional Court of Romania responded, arguing that in order for the CJEU ruling to become fully valid, the Constitution of Romania needs to be revised.

The dispute was kindled against the backdrop of a long history of discontentment and criticism at local level with respect to maintaining the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism for Romania, whereby the European Commission monitors the Romanian judiciary. The most vehement critics were politicians who’ve had run-in with the law, certain commentators and journalists, promoted first and foremost by TV stations such as Antena 3 and RTV, the former tied to Dan Voiculescu, who was handed a prison sentence himself, while the latter owned by fugitive Sebastian Ghiță. The criticism and disgruntlement were often disguised as sovereigntist rhetoric, which on the one hand recalls the communist-era official dictum about “non-interference in domestic affairs”, while on the other hand is reminiscent of certain narratives actively promoted by Russian propaganda.

In the interview for news.ro, the head of the European Commission’s Office in Bucharest, Ramona Chiriac, also spoke about the CJEU ruling, drawing attention to the prevalence of European legislation.

In the same interview, Ramona Chiriac also discussed the National Recovery and Resilience Plan, whereby Romania will be awarded nearly 30 billion Euro, provided that it abides by the rule of law and EU regulations, continues to implement reforms and achieves 507 set targets. PNRR was negotiated with Brussels before the current ruling coalition took office, and PSD wants to renegotiate its terms. However, this option has been ruled out – a change of government does not provide reasonable cause for operating any modification to the plan.

Sputnik.mid is one the Kremlin’s propaganda channels, ardently promoting sovereigntist and disinformation narratives regarding the EU and NATO. The Sputnik.mid website regularly quotes public figures from Romania, usually in a positive light, who tackle similar issues (and others as well: anti-vaxx discourse, advocates of the traditional family, etc.).

Diana Șoșoacă is one of the most controversial Romanian politicians at the moment. She too is being promoted by Sputnik, who designated her the political personality of 2021 and was the first publication to announce the Senator’s plans to run for the office of president.

PURPOSE: To undermine people’s confidence in the EU and promote sovereigntist rhetoric.

WHY THE NARRATIVES ARE FALSE: The head of the European Commission’s Office in Romania never said that Romania should renounce its Constitution or sovereignty, but merely that “the recent decision of the European Court of Justice has reaffirmed a principle that we have made crystal clear: the prevalence of European law over national law, a fundamental principle without which the EU cannot function and which every member state has pledged to observe upon being accepted in the EU. The prevalence of European legislation stipulates that national judges may disregard Constitutional Court rulings as long as they are contrary to European law.” Ramona Chiriac added that “the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism (CVM) and the European Rule of Law Mechanism […] stipulate the principle of prevalence of European law.” As regards the consequences of breaching the prevalence of European legislation, Ramona Chiriac simply replied “no” when asked if “Romania can still hope to join the Schengen Area without abiding by this CJEU ruling?” Worth noting is that the prevalence of European legislation is also clearly stipulated as a principle in the Constitution of Romania, under Chapter VI, Euro-Atlantic Integration. As a matter of fact, Romania wanted to join the EU and the political class and the population knew from the very outset that EU membership also comes with a pledge to observe and enforce European values and regulations.

In no way does PNRR reflect on Romania’s sovereignty – Bucharest simply has to observe a set of clear-cut rules so that Brussels can make sure the money will only be used to develop Romania, in a transparent way, and will not be embezzled. Therefore, the requirements set under PNRR actually benefit the population.

None of Diana Șoșoacă’s statements has any sound and factual basis: private property was never under threat in the EU, and in Romania it is guaranteed by the Constitution. Difficulties in the education system are the result of policies implemented by Romanian authorities and of the activity of people working in the system, and thus have nothing to do with the EU. The exodus of highly-trained professionals has been facilitated by free travel conditions, and is motivated by people’s search for better economic opportunities and their disgruntlement with the current political system and past attempts at subordinating the judiciary.

  • Publication / Media:
    Stiripesurse.ro, https://www.facebook.com/DianaSosoacaOficial, sputnik.md
  • Date of publication:
    03/01/2022
  • Target audience:
    Sovereigntists, Eurosceptics
  • Amplification:
    Social media, newsnow.ro, ziarelive.ro, stirilekanald.ro, realitateaecologista.net
  • Key narrative:
    UE is strongarming Romania to renounce its Constitution and sovereignty
Cătălin Gomboș

06 Jan 2022
Cătălin Gomboș

Follow us on Google News

15 minutes read
  • Romania will have to renounce its Constitution and sovereignty, according to a new disinformation amplified by Senator Diana Șoșoacă and Sputnik. The source headlines a statement falsely attributed to the head of the European Commission’s Office in Romania.
  • NARRATIVES: 1. The EU is strongarming Romania to renounce its own Constitution. 2. PNRR will lead to Romania losing its sovereignty. 3. Romania will be destroyed and turned in to a region. 4. Private property will be abolished, the education system will be destroyed, and the intellectual elites will move to other countries.
  • PURPOSE: To undermine people’s confidence in the EU and promote sovereigntist rhetoric.
DISINFORMATION: The pro-European government of Moldova is to blame for the increases in public transportation fees, introduced by the socialist mayor of Chișinău
DISINFORMATION: The pro-European government of Moldova is to blame for the increases in public transportation fees, introduced by the socialist mayor of Chișinău

The PAS government is responsible for the imminent increase in public transportation fees in Chișinău, because it allowed for an increase in fuel prices, Chișinău city hall councilman, Alexandr Odițov, has said. His statement was publicized by a number of news agencies controlled by the Socialists. In fact, fuel prices went up as a result of a global increase in energy prices.

Veridica
Veridica
16 May 2022
DISINFORMATION: Russia will be forced to resort to nuclear weapons
DISINFORMATION: Russia will be forced to resort to nuclear weapons

Putin has announced the start of World War III and will use nuclear weapons because, due to the West’s involvement, its forces cannot win the war. The narrative is promoted by Sorin Roșca Stănescu, who was given a criminal sentence and who is known for his opinions that very much resemble Russian propaganda. The Kremlin has long promoted the possible start of nuclear warfare, in order to determine the West to withdraw its support for Ukraine.

Mădălin Necșuțu
Mădălin Necșuțu
12 May 2022
DISINFORMATION: Moldova is renouncing its neutrality and is preparing to fight Russia
DISINFORMATION: Moldova is renouncing its neutrality and is preparing to fight Russia

The Government in Chișinău wants to renounce the neutrality status of the Republic of Moldova, while the West is providing this country with weapons to turn it into a living shield against Russia, the pro-Kremlin website politnavigator.net writes, reiterating narratives about Romania’s military presence in the Republic of Moldova and military support Moldova is allegedly providing to Ukraine.

Veridica
Veridica
09 May 2022
DISINFORMATION: Romanian troops, alongside Poland, Ukraine and Moldova, are preparing to invade Transnistria
DISINFORMATION: Romanian troops, alongside Poland, Ukraine and Moldova, are preparing to invade Transnistria

Romania, Poland, Ukraine and the Republic of Moldova will jointly attack the separatist region of Transnistria, according to disinformation narratives carried by the Romania media. The disinformation was published in Romania in a version that contains a number of false information, which is a typical example of Russian propaganda.

Mădălin Necșuțu
Mădălin Necșuțu
04 May 2022