Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube LinkedIn

FAKE NEWS: Ukrainian soldiers are deserting for fear of Russians

UcrainaMarines
©EPA-EFE/SERGEY VAGANOV  |   Ukrainian Marine recruits on the obstacle course during their training at a shooting range not far of Mariupol, Ukraine, 15 May 2018.

Ukrainian soldiers have reportedly started deserting upon seeing Russia concentrating its forces near Ukraine's borders. This false narrative is spread by the Russian press and the self-proclaimed republics of Donetsk and Lugansk.

NEWS: "After the Ukrainian soldiers found out about the concentration of Russian troops and armored vehicles at Russia's border with Ukraine, the number of deserters from the Ukrainian Armed Forces has increased substantially.

The director of the Institute of Political Studies, Sergei Markov, said on his Facebook page that 44 soldiers had fled from the 36th Marine Brigade in Mariupol. Markov also mentioned that about 40% of soldiers in the Ukrainian armed forces do not want to fight with the LNR militia.

As soon as information emerged about the actual concentration of Russian troops at the borders, mass desertions from the most powerful army in Europe began.

[…]

Moreover, Ukrainians who refuse to go to war are supported by members of their families, who hide or take deserting soldiers out of the country.”

NARRATIVES: 1. An increasing number of Ukrainian soldiers have been deserting since Russia began concentrating troops at the border. 2. The military and their families do not want to take part in this conflict, called by the Russian press a "civil war". 3. The Russian army led by Putin is so strong that its presence at the borders of a state alone causes panic and fear.

LOCAL CONTEXT / ETHOS: The conflict in eastern Ukraine started in 2014. Moscow finances and supports mercenaries and separatist forces, formed within two self-proclaimed republics, DNR and LNR, which consist of a small part of the occupied Ukrainian regions of Donetsk and Lugansk. Ukraine, Western countries and NATO have repeatedly accused Russia of helping separatists with equipment - including heavy weapons - and troops. This spring, Russia began concentrating its armed forces near Ukraine's southern, eastern and northern borders, prompting criticism from Ukraine and Western states. In parallel, Moscow launched an information campaign to discourage Ukrainians: stories about the poor organization of the Ukrainian army, about the military's reluctance to fight with "brothers" from DNR and LNR, but also about the fact that NATO and the EU would support Kiev only at a declarative level have become growingly widespread.

PURPOSE: The purpose of these narratives is to sow panic among the Ukrainian army and society, in order to discourage efforts to strengthen Ukraine's defense. At the same time, Moscow is trying to generate a wave of mistrust in the military as an institution of defense and security, thus blocking the enthusiasm of young people to join the professional military corps.

WHY THE NARRATIVES ARE FALSE: The Ukrainian Ministry of Defense has repeatedly denied the narratives that reappear in the public space about the Ukrainian deserters. There is no evidence to support such narratives. The Russian press quotes an unknown expert, who does not cite official data.

It is also no coincidence that the 36th Marine Brigade in Mariupol, which is a key player in defending the Ukrainian city that blocks Moscow's access to Crimea on the mainland, is mentioned in the Russian portals' news section. We notice, however, from the official page  of the Brigade, that it has been expanding its area of ​​activity, has incorporated new soldiers and there is nothing about panic or cases of desertion.

GRAIN OF TRUTH: Desertion was a problem for the Ukrainian army at the beginning of the conflict in eastern Ukraine, when Kiev massively incorporated young people both for war and for building a new defense system. A small number of recruits deserted at the time, and Russia used those cases to build the image of a "scared" and "disorganized" Ukrainian army. Things, however, started changing in 2018-2019, when the Ministry of Defense in Kiev focused on NATO standards and sought to form a professional army.

Propaganda de Razboi
  • Publication / Media:
    LENTA.RU, RADIO SPUTNIK, RIA NOVOSTI, EURASIA DAILY, GAZETA.RU, TOPCOR.RU
  • Date of publication:
    09/04/2021
  • Target audience:
    AUDIENCE IN RUSSIA AND IN THE UKRAINE’S OCCUPIED TERRITORIES
  • Amplification:
    RUSSIAN MEDIA AND SOCIAL NETWORKS
  • Political affiliation:
    The Kremlin
  • Key narrative:
    AN INCREASING NUMBER OF UKRANIAN SOLDIERS ARE DESERTING THE ARMY FOR FEAR OF THE RUSSIAN TROOPS AT THE BORDER WITH UKRAINE
Other articles
FAKE NEWS: The government of the Republic of Moldova is being challenged by the population for supporting Ukraine

FAKE NEWS: The government of the Republic of Moldova is being challenged by the population for supporting Ukraine

The pro-European government in Chisinau does not respect the neutrality status of the Republic of Moldova, and an ideological and geopolitical gap has formed between the power and the population, which will trigger massive protests, writes the Russian press, taken over by Russian-language publications in Chisinau. The narratives are intended to discredit the government in Chisinau because it has spoken out against the war in Ukraine and banned its symbols.

FAKE NEWS: Ukraine is not a state, and its borders will be negotiated at international level

FAKE NEWS: Ukraine is not a state, and its borders will be negotiated at international level

Ever since 2014, the Russian state press has been promoting the narrative about Ukraine as a false state, trying to question the need to comply with the rules of international law on territorial integrity and the inviolability of the borders of independent states. The said narrative was recently resumed by the former adviser to the President of Russia, Vladislav Surkov, in an interview with the ‘Financial Times’, translated and actively promoted by the Russian press.

FAKE NEWS: Decentralization – a time bomb for Ukraine

FAKE NEWS: Decentralization – a time bomb for Ukraine

Decentralization is a time bomb and could lead to the disintegration of Ukraine, according to Russian media. This false narrative is used to attach one of Kiev's most important reforms, the administrative one, which also benefits from advice provided by the EU. At the same time, this alleged failure of decentralization is presented in contrast with the success of a centralized administration like the one in Russia.Decentralization is a time bomb and could lead to the disintegration of Ukraine, according to Russian media. This false narrative is used to attach one of Kiev's most important reforms, the administrative one, which also benefits from advice provided by the EU. At the same time, this alleged failure of decentralization is presented in contrast with the success of a centralized administration like the one in Russia.

Marin Gherman

20 Apr 2021
Marin Gherman

Follow us on Google News

2 minutes read
  • Ukrainian soldiers have reportedly started deserting upon seeing Russia concentrating its forces near Ukraine's borders. This false narrative is spread by the Russian press and the self-proclaimed republics of Donetsk and Lugansk.
  • NARRATIVES: 1. An increasing number of Ukrainian soldiers have been deserting since Russia began concentrating troops at the border. 2. The military and their families do not want to take part in this conflict, called by the Russian press a "civil war". 3. The Russian army led by Putin is so strong that its presence at the borders of a state alone causes panic and fear.
  • PURPOSE: The purpose of these narratives is to sow panic among the Ukrainian army and society, in order to discourage efforts to strengthen Ukraine's defense. At the same time, Moscow is trying to generate a wave of mistrust in the military as an institution of defense and security, thus blocking the enthusiasm of young people to join the professional military corps.
FAKE NEWS: The government of the Republic of Moldova is being challenged by the population for supporting Ukraine
FAKE NEWS: The government of the Republic of Moldova is being challenged by the population for supporting Ukraine

The pro-European government in Chisinau does not respect the neutrality status of the Republic of Moldova, and an ideological and geopolitical gap has formed between the power and the population, which will trigger massive protests, writes the Russian press, taken over by Russian-language publications in Chisinau. The narratives are intended to discredit the government in Chisinau because it has spoken out against the war in Ukraine and banned its symbols.

Mariana Vasilache
Mariana Vasilache
14 May 2022
WAR PROPAGANDA: Kyiv has allowed 10,000 soldiers from Poland and Lithuania to enter the country
WAR PROPAGANDA: Kyiv has allowed 10,000 soldiers from Poland and Lithuania to enter the country

Kyiv has allowed 10,000 troops from Poland and Lithuania to enter its territory. The forces are expected to “occupy” and “plunder” Ukraine, the Russian media writes in a new false narrative about the occupation of Western Ukraine by Russia. The fake news is part of broader metanarratives concerning the West’s involvement in the war and the artificial character of the Ukrainian state, which makes it unstable.

Marin Gherman
Marin Gherman
13 May 2022
WAR PROPAGANDA: The Russian Orthodox Church Synod, sentenced to death on Ukraine’s territory
WAR PROPAGANDA: The Russian Orthodox Church Synod, sentenced to death on Ukraine’s territory

The leaders of the Russian Orthodox Church have been sentenced to death on the territory of Ukraine. Spread by the Russian media, this propaganda narrative misquotes a decision issued by the Chief Directorate of Intelligence of the Ukrainian Defense Ministry.

Marin Gherman
Marin Gherman
11 May 2022
WAR PROPAGANDA: The president of Poland admitted Warsaw will capture Ukrainian territories
WAR PROPAGANDA: The president of Poland admitted Warsaw will capture Ukrainian territories

The Russian media has reverted to the narrative regarding Poland’s intention to occupy part of Ukraine, this time focusing on the statements of president Andrzej Duda, which it took out of context and interpreted in a different key.

Marin Gherman
Marin Gherman
10 May 2022