Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube LinkedIn

Fake News

FAKE NEWS: Ukraine is not a state, and its borders will be negotiated at international level

Ucr
©EPA/DENIS SINYAKOV / POOL AFP POOL  |   Russian President Vladimir Putin (L) speaks with Deputy Head of the Kremlin administration Vladislav Surkov during the meeting with Russian biggest business chiefs in Moscow's Kremlin, Tuesday 06 February 2007.

Ever since 2014, the Russian state press has been promoting the narrative about Ukraine as a false state, trying to question the need to comply with the rules of international law on territorial integrity and the inviolability of the borders of independent states. The said narrative was recently resumed by the former adviser to the President of Russia, Vladislav Surkov, in an interview with the ‘Financial Times’, translated and actively promoted by the Russian press.

NEWS: “Ukrainians fully understand that their state does not really exist at the moment. I’ve said it before, Ukraine could exist in the future, as there is a national nucleus in this regard”, Surkov is quoted by the RIA Novosti agency as saying. The former politician believes that, for Ukraine to exist in the future, it must be turned into a confederation. “The state can be reformed into a confederation, in which the regions will benefit from a wide range of decision-making freedoms, Surkov says. He believes that the issue of Ukraine's borders should become a topic of international discussion.

NARRATIVES: 1. Ukraine is a false state; 2. Ukraine's borders are arguable and are a topic of debate at international relations level.

LOCAL CONTEXT / ETHOS: After the victory of the Euromaidan protesters and the overthrow of the Viktor Yanukovych regime, the Russian Federation intervened in Ukraine by invading and annexing Crimea and supporting a separatist movement in the Russian-speaking east. Separatist forces were aided by Moscow with people and equipment. Also, Russia applied the hybrid warfare technique, using large-scale propaganda and disinformation, including through the Internet and the Kremlin-affiliated media. In this context, Russia has been trying to promote narratives that attack the idea of ​​Ukraine's independence, while at the same time covering up the Kremlin's external crimes. Russia is trying to legitimize internationally the self-proclaimed Donetsk and Lugansk People's Republics. In this context, the Russian and pro-Russian press in Ukraine and in the Russian-speaking news space use every opportunity to defend the idea that the Ukrainian state is an “artificial one”, which can easily fall apart. The concept of “false state” used in hybrid warfare is applied. In this way, the aim is to discourage efforts to support the position of Kiev, which demands respect for international law. At the same time, Russia presents its actions in Donbas and Crimea as being determined by “political necessity” and “historical truth”.

PURPOSE: The purpose of these narratives is to show the international community that Ukraine is not a nation-state and should be reorganized into a confederation. Moreover, the subject of the legitimacy of Ukraine's borders is being questioned. Russia seeks to argue before the international community that, in the context of the power vacuum in Ukraine, it had to intervene in Crimea and Donbas, and the self-proclaimed republics of DNR and LNR have every right to become legitimate elements of a Ukrainian confederation.

WHY THE NARRATIVES ARE FALSE: Surkov's statements are not the point of view of a former politician, but an attempt to promote the Kremlin's narratives in information spaces other than the Russian one. While the international community, global leaders and international organizations (NATO, EU, UN, etc.) support the territorial integrity of Ukraine and condemn the annexation of Crimea and the violence in Donbas, Surkov raises the issue of borders, which could be debated in the future at various international forums. The issue of territories and borders cannot be discussed in the era of supremacy of international law, and even if it could, it would be done only in the presence of or at the initiative of Ukraine. In reality, Surkov is not interested in discussing borders, but in creating favorable contexts for Moscow to present its actions in the Donbas and Crimea as determined by political necessity, the power vacuum, Ukraine's inability, as a “false state”, to deal with its own problems. Surkov, however, gives Ukraine a chance, saying it has “a national nucleus”.  In fact, the statement in question is a continuation of the Kremlin's classic narratives. According to them, Ukraine is going to fall apart, the state will get smaller, with a nucleus in the west and center of the country, and the rest of the territories will be taken over by the neighbors, Russia included. These narratives are known in the media world as “Zhirinovsky's prophecies”. Zhirinovksy is a radical Russian politician, close to Putin, but who presents himself as an opposition leader, who has repeatedly said that Ukraine will fall apart because it is a false state, created by the Bolsheviks.Against this background, Surkov promotes the idea of Ukraine’s ​​(con) federalization to allow the self-proclaimed republics of Donetsk and Lugansk, controlled by Russia, to acquire a legal status. In this way, Moscow will be able to control Kiev’s domestic and foreign policy in order to block the European and Euro-Atlantic aspirations of Ukrainian society.

  • Publication / Media:
    Financial Times
  • Date of publication:
    18/06/2021
  • Language / Target audience:
    English-speaking readers and Russian-speaking readers in the former Soviet states
  • Amplification:
    Radio Sputnik, Ria Novosti
  • Key narrative:
    Ukraine is not a state, and its border will be negotiated at international level
Other articles
FAKE NEWS: The West wants to stir a global panic regarding Russia’s acts of aggression in Ukraine

FAKE NEWS: The West wants to stir a global panic regarding Russia’s acts of aggression in Ukraine

The West is looking for new ways to conceal its own problems by generating a wave of anxiety over the Russian threat. This false narrative has been promoted by the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, which ignores the fact that Russia has mobilized over 100 thousand military on the Ukrainian border.

FAKE NEWS: The West is using Moldova against Russia

FAKE NEWS: The West is using Moldova against Russia

Occidentul vrea să impună victoria pro-europenilor în alegerile din Republica Moldova pentru a atrage țara în lupta împotriva Rusiei. Această narațiune falsă este promovată în contextul unei campanii electorale în care forțe pro-rusești – socialiști și comuniști – caută să pună accentul pe chestiunea orientarea geopolitică a Moldovei.

FAKE NEWS: In the eyes of the USA, Transylvania doesn’t belong to Romania, just as Crimea doesn’t belong to Russia

FAKE NEWS: In the eyes of the USA, Transylvania doesn’t belong to Romania, just as Crimea doesn’t belong to Russia

Sputnik writes that the United States would validate the idea that Transylvania doesn’t belong to Romania, because the embassy didn’t delete a certain commentary posted by a Romanian on Facebook. In fact, Sputnik is trying to link the status of Crimea, occupied and annexed by Russia, to that of Transylvania.

Marin Gherman

22 Jun 2021
Marin Gherman

3 minutes read
  • Ever since 2014, the Russian state press has been promoting the narrative about Ukraine as a false state, trying to question the need to comply with the rules of international law on territorial integrity and the inviolability of the borders of independent states. The said narrative was recently resumed by the former adviser to the President of Russia, Vladislav Surkov, in an interview with the ‘Financial Times’, translated and actively promoted by the Russian press.
  • NARRATIVES: 1. Ukraine is a false state; 2. Ukraine's borders are arguable and are a topic of debate at international relations level.
  • PURPOSE: The purpose of these narratives is to show the international community that Ukraine is not a nation-state and should be reorganized into a confederation. Moreover, the subject of the legitimacy of Ukraine's borders is being questioned. Russia seeks to argue before the international community that, in the context of the power vacuum in Ukraine, it had to intervene in Crimea and Donbas, and the self-proclaimed republics of DNR and LNR have every right to become legitimate elements of a Ukrainian confederation.
FAKE NEWS: Fascist ideology sweeps through Moldova
FAKE NEWS: Fascist ideology sweeps through Moldova

“A monument devoted to fascists was inaugurated in the Republic of Moldova”, a number of media outlets in Russia have headlined, based on a piece of news published by “Steaua Roșie” news agency, actually referring to a cemetery in Fălești devoted to Romanian fallen soldiers. Arctus.livejournal.com uses the article to bring back in the limelight the narratives about the Romanian Army allegedly having exterminated the civilian population in the Republic of Moldova and about the existence of two different peoples – Romanians and Moldovans.

Cornel Ciobanu
Cornel Ciobanu
20 Sep 2021
FAKE NEWS: Klaus Iohannis caused the political crisis in Romania in order to make the future government in Bucharest subservient to the German left wing
FAKE NEWS: Klaus Iohannis caused the political crisis in Romania in order to make the future government in Bucharest subservient to the German left wing

The political crisis in Romania was deliberately caused by president Klaus Iohannis, who wants to align the future government in Romania, made up of PNL and PSD, a rehashed version of the former USL, with the German Social-Democrats, who are expected to win the election in Germany.

15 Sep 2021
FAKE NEWS: The pro-European regime in Chișinău reintroduces the ban on Russian TV stations
FAKE NEWS: The pro-European regime in Chișinău reintroduces the ban on Russian TV stations

The pro-European regime in Chișinău plans on reintroducing the ban on Russian television stations, the Moldovan media writes, referring to a statement of Parliament Speaker, Igor Grosu. In fact, the Moldovan official referred to the protection and stimulation of the local audiovisual sector, including by passing a piece of legislation to give it a wider access to the media market, considering it is presently dominated by stations broadcasting TV programmes from other countries. The misinterpretation is part of a wider campaign aimed at demonizing the pro-European regime in Chișinău and to depict it as anti-Russian, ready to engage in a war pitting the West against Moscow.

Cornel Ciobanu
Cornel Ciobanu
13 Sep 2021
FAKE NEWS: Ukraine is using Transnistria to draw Moldova into a conflict with Russia
FAKE NEWS: Ukraine is using Transnistria to draw Moldova into a conflict with Russia

The new government in Chisinau is blindly following the agenda dictated by Washington and Brussels and Ukraine is trying to draw the Republic of Moldova into a conflict against Russia, according to older narratives resumed by the PSRM leader Igor Dodon. In an interview on the Moldovan TV station ‘Primul’, Dodon also said that the authorities in Chisinau and Kiev agreed to economically block the Transnistrian region.

Mariana Vasilache
Mariana Vasilache
10 Sep 2021