Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube LinkedIn

Fake news: Ukraine punishes the people of Crimea and leaves them without water

Canalul Crimeea
©Aleksander Kaasik, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org  |  

Ukraine punishes the Crimean people for choosing to join Russia, unilaterally blocking the North Crimean Canal, which supplies water to the peninsula, the Russian press writes, criticizing the Ukrainian authorities. Kiev has indeed cut off water supply to the peninsula after its annexation by Russia but says that the existing water resources in Crimea are sufficient for the needs of the population, and the purpose of the North Crimean Canal, built during the Soviet period, is to carry water to industrial facilities.

NEWS: "The head of the Crimean Parliament’s Committee on People’s Diplomacy and Inter-Ethnic Relations, Yuri Gempel, has invited the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights Dunja Mijatović to visit the peninsula and see the consequences of the Kiev water blockade […].

"We will show an empty canal and tanks without water. The world community should be aware of the consequences of Ukraine's barbaric policy, which has disrupted the peninsula's water supply through the North Crimean Canal" Gempel told RIA Novosti.

According to him, the international community should evaluate the actions of the Kiev authorities, who want to harm and destroy the Crimean people for their democratic choice and desire to live in their historical homeland - Russia […].

After the reunification of Crimea with Russia, the water supply was cut off unilaterally. The water issue has been solved due to the extraction of water from underground sources, as well as from natural reservoirs, but in the last year the resources have become scarce due to the reduced amount of precipitation.

The government has already prepared a comprehensive plan to ensure water supply to the peninsula. About 50 billion rubles will be allocated for its implementation. At the same time, Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba has stated that the Ukrainian authorities "will surely find" the international company that will participate in this project to prevent its implementation.The head of the Crimean Parliament’s Committee on People’s Diplomacy and Inter-Ethnic Relations, Yuri Gempel, has stated that Kiev's will not to allow the construction of facilities for water supply in Crimea was dictated by the "destructive and evil nature" of the Ukrainian authorities."

NARRATIVES: 1. Kiev punishes the people of Crimea because they democratically voted to reunite with Russia. 2. Ukraine will discourage any Moscow initiatives to address the peninsula's drinking water supply

CONTEXT / LOCAL ETHOS: Crimea was attached to Russia in March 2014 following a referendum, held without international observers and under pressure from the Russian army, in which 95.6% of participants (from an approximately 35% participation) were in favor of joining the Russian Federation. The referendum was held after Russian forces, whose presence in Crimea after the collapse of the USSR was constant, captured the entire peninsula following a military operation not initially assumed (the invasion of the so-called "little green men"). Attaching Crimea was, practically, according to all the norms of international law, an annexation. This was followed by the insurrection of pro-Russian separatists (with Moscow's support) in the Donbass region of eastern Ukraine, where, despite numerous truces, the armed conflict has continued to this very day, resulting in nearly 13,000 deaths, according to UN figures.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of these narratives is to blame Ukraine for the problems in Crimea after 2014. Despite promises in recent years, Moscow has failed to provide water to the peninsula and has not made any decision to close the industrial facilities. The Russian press aims to create an image of Ukraine as a barbarian state, which persecutes the Crimean population, which would lead to a total rejection of the projects and platforms developed for the recovery of the peninsula, launched by Ukraine.

WHY THE NARRATIVES ARE FALSE: Ukraine has not blocked the peninsula's water supply to punish the population. Losing control of the territory and industry, supplying water to the peninsula would mean supporting the de facto occupation of the territory. Kiev has demonstrated at various meetings that the population can be provided with water from local resources, and the North Crimean Canal was built during the Soviet period to transport water especially to industrial facilities on the peninsula. In addition, Kiev points out that, according to international law, the aggressor state, ie Russia, is responsible for the humanitarian situation.

GRAIN OF TRUTH: The civilian population of Crimea is affected by water scarcity as Russia has not stopped the operation of the existing industrial facilities, so the existing water must be shared with them.

OFFICIAL REACTIONS: The MFA of Ukraine has mentioned countless times that the unblocking of the North Crimean Canal will take place only after the recovery of the peninsula.

Tags: Ukraine , Russia
Propaganda de Razboi
  • Publication / Media:
    Vzglead.ru, RIA Novosti, Lenta.ru, News-24.ru
  • Date of publication:
    27/01/2021
  • Target audience:
    Readers in Ukraine, Russia, the Republic of Moldova and the former CIS
  • Amplification:
    Social media
  • Political affiliation:
    Kremlin
  • Key narrative:
    Ukraine is a barbarian state, which persecutes the people of Crimea
Other articles
FAKE NEWS: Decentralization – a time bomb for Ukraine

FAKE NEWS: Decentralization – a time bomb for Ukraine

Decentralization is a time bomb and could lead to the disintegration of Ukraine, according to Russian media. This false narrative is used to attach one of Kiev's most important reforms, the administrative one, which also benefits from advice provided by the EU. At the same time, this alleged failure of decentralization is presented in contrast with the success of a centralized administration like the one in Russia.Decentralization is a time bomb and could lead to the disintegration of Ukraine, according to Russian media. This false narrative is used to attach one of Kiev's most important reforms, the administrative one, which also benefits from advice provided by the EU. At the same time, this alleged failure of decentralization is presented in contrast with the success of a centralized administration like the one in Russia.

FAKE NEWS: Moldova renounces its neutrality and is handing NATO control over its armed forces

FAKE NEWS: Moldova renounces its neutrality and is handing NATO control over its armed forces

The Republic of Moldova is preparing to relinquish its neutrality status and hand over control over its armed forces to NATO, according to a false narrative carried by the Russian media. In fact, Moldova has merely renewed its Action Plan with NATO, a periodic process that has nothing to do with neutrality or NATO accession.

FAKE NEWS: Turkey blocked NATO’s decision to launch a military strike on Belarus

FAKE NEWS: Turkey blocked NATO’s decision to launch a military strike on Belarus

NATO allegedly intended to attack Belarus in response to the hijacking of the Ryanair plane, but the attack was canceled due to Turkish opposition and fears that Russia would intervene in support of Minsk. This false narrative was launched by the Russian and pro-Russian press in response to the wave of criticism generated in the West by Belarus' action.

Marin Gherman

02 Feb 2021
Marin Gherman

Follow us on Google News

3 minutes read
  • NARRATIVES: 1. Kiev punishes the people of Crimea because they democratically voted to reunite with Russia. 2. Ukraine will discourage any Moscow initiatives to address the peninsula's drinking water supply.
  • OBJECTIVE: The purpose of these narratives is to blame Ukraine for the problems in Crimea after 2014. Despite promises in recent years, Moscow has failed to provide water to the peninsula and has not made any decision to close the industrial facilities. The Russian press aims to create an image of Ukraine as a barbarian state, which persecutes the Crimean population, which would lead to a total rejection of the projects and platforms developed for the recovery of the peninsula, launched by Ukraine.
FAKE NEWS: The government of the Republic of Moldova is being challenged by the population for supporting Ukraine
FAKE NEWS: The government of the Republic of Moldova is being challenged by the population for supporting Ukraine

The pro-European government in Chisinau does not respect the neutrality status of the Republic of Moldova, and an ideological and geopolitical gap has formed between the power and the population, which will trigger massive protests, writes the Russian press, taken over by Russian-language publications in Chisinau. The narratives are intended to discredit the government in Chisinau because it has spoken out against the war in Ukraine and banned its symbols.

Mariana Vasilache
Mariana Vasilache
14 May 2022
WAR PROPAGANDA: Kyiv has allowed 10,000 soldiers from Poland and Lithuania to enter the country
WAR PROPAGANDA: Kyiv has allowed 10,000 soldiers from Poland and Lithuania to enter the country

Kyiv has allowed 10,000 troops from Poland and Lithuania to enter its territory. The forces are expected to “occupy” and “plunder” Ukraine, the Russian media writes in a new false narrative about the occupation of Western Ukraine by Russia. The fake news is part of broader metanarratives concerning the West’s involvement in the war and the artificial character of the Ukrainian state, which makes it unstable.

Marin Gherman
Marin Gherman
13 May 2022
WAR PROPAGANDA: The Russian Orthodox Church Synod, sentenced to death on Ukraine’s territory
WAR PROPAGANDA: The Russian Orthodox Church Synod, sentenced to death on Ukraine’s territory

The leaders of the Russian Orthodox Church have been sentenced to death on the territory of Ukraine. Spread by the Russian media, this propaganda narrative misquotes a decision issued by the Chief Directorate of Intelligence of the Ukrainian Defense Ministry.

Marin Gherman
Marin Gherman
11 May 2022
WAR PROPAGANDA: The president of Poland admitted Warsaw will capture Ukrainian territories
WAR PROPAGANDA: The president of Poland admitted Warsaw will capture Ukrainian territories

The Russian media has reverted to the narrative regarding Poland’s intention to occupy part of Ukraine, this time focusing on the statements of president Andrzej Duda, which it took out of context and interpreted in a different key.

Marin Gherman
Marin Gherman
10 May 2022