DISINFORMATION: Putin is a good Christian, a victim of the Russophobic discourse, and has nothing to do with Communism, imposed on Russia by the West

DISINFORMATION: Putin is a good Christian, a victim of the Russophobic discourse, and has nothing to do with Communism, imposed on Russia by the West
© EPA-EFE/ROBERT GHEMENT   |   Orthodox archbishop Teodosie (R, in blue) blesses worshipers with holy water after an Epiphany mass held at Tomis seaport in Constanta city, eastern Romania, 06 January 2022.
Disinformation:

Vladimir Putin is a good Christian, but his image has suffered because of Russophobia. These false narratives are based on statements made by the Archbishop of Thomis, Theodosius, and amplified by Sputnik. At the same time, the idea that Putin and Russia have nothing to do with Communism, which was imposed by the West, is also promoted.

NEWS: “In full Russophobic and anti-Putin propaganda, His Eminence Theodosius, Archbishop of Thomis, takes the stage again with a surprising opinion about Russia’s president.

 [...]

"Mr. Putin, who is on everybody’s lips these days and portrayed in dark colors, is not as dark as they say”, His Eminence Theodosius said during this weekly show on Radio Dobrogea. “I have said it and I say it again without fear and without any hesitation: he is the greatest founder at the Holy Mountain and in Jerusalem. In their country, both Putin and Medvedev are founders. And I took a trip to follow in their footsteps and I marveled at their sacrifice”. The archbishop also drew attention to an important issue. There is a dimension of Russophobic and Putinophobic propaganda that links Russia and everything that is Russian to the tragic memory of Communism.Communism as an ideology, His Eminence Theodosius says, is not a Russian product. Marx and Engels, the fathers of communism, were German intellectuals, trained at the great universities of the West, who wrote their work and laid the foundations of communist ideology in Paris and London, not in Moscow and St. Petersburg.

 […]

The love for the Romanian people, for their freedom, for their Christian values, for their humor and their feelings, many “politically incorrect”, but justified by life: this is the real opponent of Russophobic propaganda.

 […]

The historical shadows of the relationship between Romanians and Russians seem, at least in Romania’s official policies, to be the ones that matter in defining the relations between the two states. The Romanian eastern policy is simply marked by a false but dark historical memory of the unfriendliness between Russians and Romanians.

 [...]

Simply criticizing, saying things by their name, not being in line with the official direction, is denounced as a Russian action. For an increasingly intellectually challenged political class, with no love for their country, Russophobia seems to have become a substitute for patriotism.But the reason behind it is perverse. The servitude to the current “strategic partners”, the fact that Romania has increasingly grown into an appendix to the regional interests of some great powers in the Black Sea region, the fact that our resources are given away without negotiation and that the fight against corruption has liquidated the power poles in Romania more effectively than the “class struggle” had done in the 1950's, had to be somehow justified.Likewise, the revolution of immorality, which probably upset the settlement of Romanian society beyond repair, had to be explained and defended. And the best defense was to invoke an alleged “Russian alternative”, which would be more frightening. [...] ”

Reality:

NARRATIVES: 1. Vladimir Putin is better than the Putophobic and Russophobic propaganda portrays him and has sacrificed himself for the Church. 2. Russia has nothing to do with communism, which is not a Russian product, but a Western one. 3. The official discourse in Romania is a Russophobic one. 4. The history of Russia's hostile actions towards Romania is false. 5. Russophobia is used to hide the lack of patriotism, the transformation of Romania into a colony of the West, the undermining of the traditional values ​​of Romanian society. 6. The fight against corruption liquidated the poles of power in Romania.

LOCAL CONTEXT / ETHOS: Vladimir Putin's image is now associated by many with Russia's aggressive policy and the risk of it invading Ukraine again, triggering a new war in Europe. At the same time, Putin's image has suffered as a result of news of his regime's numerous anti-democratic slips, so attempts are now being made to beautify that image. The Archbishop of Thomis, Theodosius, is one of the most controversial figures of the Romanian Orthodox Church. Theodosius signed an agreement with the former political police (Securitate) and was involved in several criminal cases . With the onset of the Covid pandemic, Theodosius became a voice of the Corona-skeptics and anti-vaxxers of the Romanian Orthodox Church and has repeatedly refused to abide by the regulations in force.

Theodosius has made many controversial statements over time, some of which the very Orthodox Church distanced itself from.  On the other hand, the Archbishop of Thomis is appreciated by the Kremlin-affiliated press, which praises him as one of the main figures of sovereignism in Romania

The Archbishop of Tomis has been declared by Sputnik the public personality of the year 2021  and   the man of the year 2020.

The excerpt about Vladimir Putin and Dmitry Medvedev is part of a broader answer given by the Archbishop to a listener  (the entire excerpt can be found in the recording of the show, starting at minute 26'31), who wanted to know if using bank cards is a sin, as they have chips. The question refers to a conspiracy theory circulated in the ultra-religious circles, according to which the chips are marked with the “sign of the Beast”, number 666. The leader of this trend was Iustin Pârvu, a clergyman and abbot of Petru Voda Monastery, also associated with the Legionary Movement - there are recordings on the internet in which, on the occasion of his 92nd birthday, nuns are singing to  Iustin Pârvu the hymn “Holy Legionary Youth” .

Iustin Pârvu, who passed away in 2013, is seen as one of the early opponents of the so-called “biometric dictatorship” (another conspiracy theory that largely overlaps and is sometimes confused with that of “the sign of the Beast”). And is also associated with the current anti-vaccination movement promoted by ActiveNews. This online publication, which promotes various corona-skeptic and anti-vax conspiracy theories (the Great Reset), claims that Iustin Pârvu had prophesied the chip implantations and the emergence of the Green Certificate .

Theodosius - also promoted by ActiveNews - distances himself from the conspiracy theory regarding the “sign of the Beast” and claims that he told Iustin Pârvu, to whom he says he was “very close [...] and I confessed to him, and he confessed to me too”, that, beyond its symbolic meaning, the number 666 is a common one and its mere use or pronunciation cannot do any harm, as evidenced by the fact that the number is written even in the Bible.Theodosius makes a digression from his explanations of the number 666 in which he begins by mentioning that the end of the world is now being spoken of (he does not say explicitly why he made the switch, but 666 appears as a sign of the Beast in Revelation), mentions St. Nicholas, a Russian apostle born in Smolensk, who in his opinion founded the first Christian mission in Japan in the 19th century – which is false information, given that Catholic missionaries had arrived in the Japanese archipelago in the 16th century -, moves on to  the Russian presence at the “Holy Mountain” (Athos) and the “sacred places” (Israel and the West Bank) and then makes the statements about Putin and Medvedev that were also taken over by Sputnik. Theodosius further distances Putin and Medvedev from communism and says that communism was “planted” by the West and “Marx and Engels are not from Russia. They have a different origin”.

PURPOSE:  To clear the image of Vladimir Putin especially in the eyes of Orthodox believers, but also to present the Russian leader as a victim, a target of “Russophobia” and Putophobia. To shift attention from Russia's aggressive actions and justify its position in the context of the current crisis on the borders of Ukraine. To beatify history in order to distance Russia from communism, but also to hide its many hostile acts in the relationship with Romania.

WHY THE NARRATIVES ARE FALSE: Many authoritarian leaders and dictators have over time sought to publicly emphasize their pious side and approach religious authorities in an attempt to increase their popularity and gain legitimacy. One such example is Saddam Hussein, who, although a member of a secular political movement and ordered measures to secularize Iraqi society in his early years in power, changed his mind after becoming an outcast for the international community following the invasion of Kuwait. In his quest to gain the support of the Muslim world, Saddam gave religious leaders more freedom, ordered that Allah al-akbar be written on the Iraqi flag (in his very own handwriting, they say), had the Qur'an written in his own blood and ordered the building of more mosques. This piety displayed by the dictator does not mean that he is no longer guilty of the mass crimes he committed, nor that he stopped committing those crimes after he wrote Allah al-akbar on the flag - on the contrary, some of the biggest ones were committed after that episode.

Similarly, the fact that Vladimir Putin allowed funds to be allocated to the Church and encouraged the construction / equipping of some establishments did not smooth the nature of his regime. The Russian Orthodox Church is one of Vladimir Putin’s major allies , and Patriarch Cyril had ties to the KGB, whose member Vladimir Putin used to be as well. The relations between the Kremlin and the Church have strengthened as Putin's authoritarian regime has become stronger and more and more measures have been taken against the opposition, civil society and the independent media. In fact, the Church is a source of legitimacy meant to make up for the loss of democratic legitimacy. The relations with the Church have not prevented Vladimir Putin from engaging in a series of wars and aggressions throughout his rule: the bloody campaign in Chechnya, the war against Georgia, the intervention in Syria, where Russian warplanes bombed civilian targets too, including hospitals, the invasion of Ukraine. Vladimir Putin is an authoritarian leader whose internal opponents have on many occasions been assassinated or imprisoned and whose armed forces have committed aggression and war crimes, all of which are acts that run counter to the values ​​promoted by the Church.

While it is true that Marx and Engels were not Russians, the idea of ​​a communist regime is associated with Russia, the country in which communist ideology was applied as interpreted by local leaders, starting with Lenin. The latter initiated the Bolshevik revolution, was the supreme leader of the communists during the civil war, and the founder of the USSR was Russian. Russia was the dominant force, which gave the most union leaders during the existence of the USSR, and the USSR is the power that forcibly imposed communism in Eastern Europe and also supported various communist organizations in the West. Nowhere in the Western states has power been taken over by local communist movements that claim to have ideologically stemming from Marx and Engels.

Even though Vladimir Putin could not have been one of the communist initiators, because of the time he was born in, the Russian leader comes from a family of communists –  Putin’s grandfather worked as a cook for both Lenin and Stalin, his father worked for the dreaded NKVD - he himself was a member of the Communist Party and an officer of the dreaded Soviet intelligence service, the KGB, and expressed his admiration for the USSR, whose dismemberment he described as “the greatest geopolitical catastrophe” of the twentieth century. Russia's aggressive policy under Putin's rule, the wars against Georgia and Ukraine, or the demands for NATO to pull back its forces to the pre -1997 lines show, in fact, that Putin is claiming exactly the territory of the Soviet empire.

Romania's political discourse is termed as Russophobic because Romania has adopted the position of its Western allies and partners, criticized Russia's aggressive policies, and advocated for the restoration of historical truth about Russia's relations. These have been marked by aggression, hostile acts and territorial plunder starting with the annexation of Bessarabia in 1812, the seizing of the counties of southern Bessarabia in 1871 - although the United Principalities had just fought as Russia's ally in the war against the Ottoman Empire – the confiscation of the Treasury, the invention of Moldovanism to justify territorial claims on Romania, the territorial robbery that followed the Soviet pact with Nazi Germany, etc.

The false narratives about sovereignism, western colonization or traditional values  are part of the usual arsenal used by Moscow both in its official propaganda and in the media and online media campaigns consisting of fake news and disinformation.

The fight against corruption did not target the structures of the Romanian state or its balance, on the contrary, its purpose is precisely to build a strong rule of law, in which the powers are separate, citizens are equal before the law and different interest groups - basically criminal groups – are not above the law.

OFFICIAL REACTIONS: The Romanian Orthodox Church has distanced itself from Theodosius’ statements about Putin in a message that reads:  “As it is already known, Archbishop Theodosius often provides “sui generis” opinions, including on topics that are not related to the church. By virtue of the eparchial autonomy he enjoys and which he often chooses to use in an original way, he is of course entitled to express himself freely on any subject, without this meaning that he is speaking on behalf of the Romanian Orthodox Church.  Especially when he voices his preferences or various affinities in relation to certain people”.

  • Publication / Media:
    sputnik.md, Radio Dobrogea
  • Date of publication:
    09/02/2022
  • Target audience:
    Orthodox believers, sovereigntists, defenders of “traditional values”, pro-Russians, people sharing the ideas disseminated by the Archbishop of Thomis
  • Political affiliation:
    the Kremlin
  • Key narrative:
    Putin is a good Christian, a victim of the Russophobic discourse, and has nothing to do with Communism, imposed on Russia by the West
Report
Fake News

Disinformation uses a variety of manipulation tactics. Disinformation stories can easily be created by combining provocative topics.

Report
Other news
FAKE NEWS: Moldovans are forced to speak the language of the Romanian minority

FAKE NEWS: Moldovans are forced to speak the language of the Romanian minority

The language of the Romanian minority has been forcefully imposed in the Republic of Moldova, pro-Russian propaganda writes, repeating the false thesis about the existence of two nations, Moldovans and Romanians, who speak different languages.

WAR PROPAGANDA: Only union with Russia can save Ukraine

WAR PROPAGANDA: Only union with Russia can save Ukraine

Ukraine is going through a crisis similar to that of the 17th century and, as then, only union with Russia can save it, according to pro-Kremlin propaganda.

FAKE NEWS: Baltic States have lost their independence

FAKE NEWS: Baltic States have lost their independence

Baltic States have become colonies of the USA, acting only on Washington’s orders, according to Russian propaganda in Romania.

EBOOK> Razboi si propaganda: O cronologie a conflictului ruso-ucrainean

EBOOK>Razboiul lui Putin cu lumea libera: Propaganda, dezinformare, fake news

Read time: 2 min

Follow us on Google News

Article highlights:
  • Vladimir Putin is a good Christian, but his image has suffered because of Russophobia. These false narratives are based on statements made by the Archbishop of Thomis, Theodosius, and amplified by Sputnik. At the same time, the idea that Putin and Russia have nothing to do with Communism, which was imposed by the West, is also promoted.
  • NARRATIVES: 1. Vladimir Putin is better than the Putophobic and Russophobic propaganda portrays him and has sacrificed himself for the Church. 2. Russia has nothing to do with communism, which is not a Russian product, but a Western one. 3. The official discourse in Romania is a Russophobic one. 4. The history of Russia's hostile actions towards Romania is false. 5. Russophobia is used to hide the lack of patriotism, the transformation of Romania into a colony of the West, the undermining of the traditional values of Romanian society. 6. The fight against corruption liquidated the poles of power in Romania.
  • PURPOSE: To clear the image of Vladimir Putin especially in the eyes of Orthodox believers, but also to present the Russian leader as a victim, a target of “Russophobia” and Putophobia. To shift attention from Russia's aggressive actions and justify its position in the context of the current crisis on the borders of Ukraine. To beatify history in order to distance Russia from communism, but also to hide its many hostile acts in the relationship with Romania.
More
DISINFORMATION: London supports neo-Nazi Ukraine to turn it into a colony
DISINFORMATION: London supports neo-Nazi Ukraine to turn it into a colony

Britain is funding the neo-Nazi regime in Kyiv to turn Ukraine into a British colony, according to pro-Kremlin propaganda citing Putin’s adviser.

Marin Gherman
31 Jan 2025
FAKE NEWS: The EU caused theThe EU's Russophobia led to the interruption of gas deliveries to Transnistria and the increase in energy prices on the right bank of the Dniester, Russian propaganda claims, ignoring the fact that Gazprom chose to stop supplying gas. energy crisis in Moldova
FAKE NEWS: The EU caused theThe EU's Russophobia led to the interruption of gas deliveries to Transnistria and the increase in energy prices on the right bank of the Dniester, Russian propaganda claims, ignoring the fact that Gazprom chose to stop supplying gas. energy crisis in Moldova

Rusofobia UE a dus la oprirea livrărilor de gaze spre Transnitria și creșterea prețurilor la energie în dreapta Nistrului, afirmă propaganda rusă, care ignoră faptul că Gazpromul a ales să nu mai dea gaze.

Veridica
30 Jan 2025
WAR PROPAGANDA: Zelensky risks suspension for mental health issues
WAR PROPAGANDA: Zelensky risks suspension for mental health issues

Ukraine's parliament could suspend Volodymyr Zelensky as president due to mental health issues, according to pro-Kremlin propaganda.

Marin Gherman
29 Jan 2025
FAKE NEWS: The annulment of the election, implemented before the Court's ruling
FAKE NEWS: The annulment of the election, implemented before the Court's ruling

The “coup d'état” is proven by the fact that the decision to cancel the election was implemented before the Constitutional Court’s ruling, a well-known conspiracy attorney claims.

Cezar Manu
27 Jan 2025
DISINFORMATION: The US calls for Zelensky to be sentenced to life in prison
DISINFORMATION: The US calls for Zelensky to be sentenced to life in prison

American society calls for Zelensky to be sentenced to life in prison for starting the war in Ukraine and killing civilians, according to pro-Kremlin media.

Marin Gherman
24 Jan 2025
FAKE NEWS: NATO wants Romania and Moldova to provide cannon fodder for a possible war with Russia
FAKE NEWS: NATO wants Romania and Moldova to provide cannon fodder for a possible war with Russia

The USA and NATO will use Romania and Moldova as anti-Russian outposts and suppliers of cannon fodder in the war against Russia, Russian propaganda writes, referring to a routine military exercise.

Veridica
23 Jan 2025