Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube LinkedIn Telegram

DISINFORMATION: Romania threatens the Republic of Moldova, although it won’t be able to do anything once NATO abandons it

Disinformation

Romania threatens the existence of the Republic of Moldova, although it is a weak state that will lose all its influence when NATO, caving in to Russia’s pressure, will shut down its bases on Romanian territory. The narratives are launched in the context of growing regional tensions and Russia’s requests that NATO should pull back to the West.

NEWS: “One of the constant threats to Moldovan statehood is Romania, a country that refuses to acknowledge the independence of Moldova. This point of view has been expressed by the Israeli statesman, diplomat and military and political expert, Yaakov Kedmi, the former head of the Nativ intelligence service. Kedmi spoke to Nina Dimoglo in “Top News”, a show broadcast by YouTube and Sputnik Moldova, Noi.md writes.

“The corruption of representatives of Moldovan political elites and their overall political and cultural standing, which has been dropping sharply, are hampering Moldova’s progress. And these aspects are obstructing the creation of a truly powerful and independent state. This causes many difficulties after thirty years of independence. Neighboring states, Romania first and foremost, should accept the fact that Moldova is an independent state, and that the Moldovan people is different from the Romanian one. Therefore, one of the constant threats to Moldovan statehood is Romania, a country that refuses to acknowledge the independence of Moldova”, the expert argues.

At the same time, Yaakov Kedmi warned that Romania today has accomplished much less at all levels, including in terms of its economy and politics, then it did a few years ago. “Romania’s economy no longer strengthens the state. If America closes its military bases in Romania, as a result of negotiations between Russia and the United States or in response to Russia’s actions, then this would further weaken Romania’s leadership and those who’ve always tried to convince the Romanian people that the presence of American military bases and NATO troops on the country’s territory will only benefit the state. If the Americans pull out from Romania, and especially if they withdraw shamed by Russia’s display of strength, then this would further weaken both Romania, as well as pro-Romanian attitudes in the region, including in Moldova. In its negotiations with the United States, Russia has demanded the shutdown of all American military bases in Romania”, military and political expert and the former head of the Nativ Israeli intelligence service, Yaakov Kedmi, said.

Reality

NARRATIVES: 1. Romania poses a constant threat to Moldovan statehood and refuses to recognize Moldova as an independent state. 2. Moldovans are a different nation from Romanians. 3. Romania has an underdeveloped economy, which will be further weakened by America’s withdrawal. 4. America will close down its military bases in Romania as a result of negotiations between Russia and the USA.

BACKGROUND: Debates about the unification of the Republic of Moldova and Romania have been ongoing ever since Moldova declared its independence from the USSR in 1991. Moldova’s territory is inhabited by Romanian ethnics. The country was originally a part of the Moldovan Principality in the Middle Ages and then part of Greater Romania. The restructuring of the USSR, a process launched by Gorbachev in the mid-1980s, saw at its peak a massive surge of nationalist claims in most Soviet republics, which were all dismissed by the Soviet authorities. The territory of the Republic of Moldova was annexed by the USSR in 1940, torn away from Romania as part of the secret agreement between Hitler and Stalin, enshrined in the Ribbentrop-Molotov Pact. Nevertheless, the rebirth of Romanian identity in Moldova (which only part of the population aspired to), did not also bring about any significant support for political parties that advocated the unification with Romania, either overtly or covertly. Unionist parties didn’t even manage to meet the electoral threshold in the latest elections, which would have allowed them to be represented in Parliament.

On the other hand, Romania is one of the most vocal champions of Moldova’s European integration, and pro-European parties have had more political success. Basically, starting 2009, Moldovan politics has been dominated for its most part by political factions with a pro-European ideology, which was not always supported by pro-European policies or the observance of EU values. Even prior to 2009, Moldova had been taking steps to establish closer ties with the EU, including during the Communists’ term in office.

Romania not only lobbied for the Republic of Moldova, but has also provided direct support to this country, the aggregate effect of which has been substantial. Romania’s right of return policy basically transformed hundreds of thousands of Moldovan citizens into citizens of the European Union. Their direct involvement in Western societies, their direct contact with Romania, which has allowed them to see for themselves the benefits of European integration and how it can lead to a substantial economic growth as well as the reform of the state (which, despite all the drawbacks reported over the years, did progress a lot compared to Moldova), has helped strengthen pro-European sentiment and was one of the factors that tipped the balance in the election race in favor of pro-European, reformist parties.

The answer of Russian propaganda and pro-Kremlin political forces in the Republic of Moldova to the national rebirth movement of the 1990s was to breathe new life into Soviet narratives regarding the existence of two separate nations, Moldovans and Romanians, the latter depicted as an aggressor who illegally occupied the territory of Moldova, first in 1918, and then later, alongside Nazi occupation troops, Romanians also being described as “fascists” or their successors.

In a similar fashion, the response to surging pro-European sentiment was to inoculate a worldview centered on geopolitics and expansionism. In order to undermine Moldova’s efforts to join the Western family, any support provided by Western powers and Romania was presented as part of a wider plan to take over the Republic of Moldova and even destroy it altogether.

Narratives regarding Romania are rehashed in the context of growing tensions in the region and in light of the demands the Kremlin advanced to the USA and NATO. The Republic of Moldova is close to Ukraine, on whose border Russia has rallied a sizable military force, the Kremlin again threatening to invade this country. Against this backdrop, Russia has demanded security guarantees from the United States and NATO, calling on them not to expand eastwards, in particular in Ukraine, and to immediately withdraw all military infrastructure from countries on the eastern flank of NATO, specifically referring in this respect to Romania and Bulgaria.

The Republic of Moldova currently observes a status of neutrality, although Russian troops are illegally stationed on its territory. Ukraine and Georgia have expressed their willingness to join NATO after they were attacked by Russia in 2008 and 2014, respectively. Romania became a NATO member in 2004.

Yaakov Kedmi is described as the former head of the Nativ Israeli intelligence service. In fact, Nativ is an Israeli government organization that was charged with liaising with Jews living in the Soviet Union and countries in the Eastern bloc and with their repatriation to Israel. Yaakov Kedmi, born Yakov Kazakóv in Moscow, in 1947, also moved to Israel in 1969, and was indeed the head of this organization for a time. In recent years, Kedmi has been invited to express his opinion as a political expert on various Russian TV and radio stations that promote official Kremlin policy, and he is often quoted by Russian propaganda.

PURPOSE: The narratives are designed to present Romania as a state that advances territorial claims regarding the Republic of Moldova. At the same time, they are meant to undermine the Romanian identity of the majority population of the Republic of Moldova.

WHY THE NARRATIVES ARE FALSE: Romania was the first state to recognize the independence of the Republic of Moldova, shortly after its proclamation in 1991, and Bucharest’s official position was always to observe the sovereignty and territorial integrity of the Republic of Moldova. No ruling party in Romania ever advanced a territorial claim concerning the Republic of Moldova. On the contrary, under the Strategic Partnership between Romania and the Republic of Moldova, Bucharest supports economic and social cooperation and large-scale infrastructure projects, as well as other projects implemented at the level of local communities.

On the other hand, Russia, a country that triggered and backed a war in the breakaway region of Transnistria in 1992, continues to support the separatist regime in Tiraspol and to maintain an illegal military force on the ground, despite protests voiced by Chișinău and the international community and despite its own committments to withdraw its troops.

Romania fully embraced Euro-Atlantic integration in the mid 1990s. After implementing consistent reforms, it was granted access to both NATO and the EU. Pre-accession reforms and particularly the benefits of NATO and EU membership have led to one of the most consistent economic growth rates in the world in the first two decades of the 21st century, a significant reduction of the development gap compared to Western states and a substantial progress compared to ex-Soviet countries that made little headway after the collapse of the USSR. Romania’s economy is not reliant on NATO’s bases on its territory, and the impact of a possible withdrawal of NATO troops would at most impact the confidence of certain investors. This too is debatable, considering that, in economic terms, Romania is anchored in the European single market and its economic relations are primarily targeting European countries.

However, a NATO withdrawal from Romania remains highly unlikely. Under no circumstance might such a scenario actually occur in response to Russia’s request, because this would basically entail the de facto collapse of the Alliance. If NATO gives in to the aggression of a foreign power, the act would violate its own rationale. As a matter of fact, no NATO official ever made any statement that would suggest the withdrawal is even considered at hypothetical level.

GRAIN OF TRUTH: The Republic of Moldova is seen as a second Romanian state, but that doesn’t mean Romania has lodged any claims regarding Moldova’s sovereingty. 

Tags: Republica Moldova , Russia , NATO , the union of the Republic of Moldova with Romania , Ukraine crisis
  • Publication / Media:
    The Soloviov Live YouTube channel, Sputnik
  • Date of publication:
    13/01/2022
  • Target audience:
    Anti-Western, anti-NATO, and pro-Russian readers
  • Amplification:
    noi.md
  • Political affiliation:
    PSRM, the Kremlin
  • Key narrative:
    Romania poses a threat to the statehood of the Republic of Moldova
Mariana Vasilache

21 Jan 2022

Updated at: 21 Jan 2022 15:13:58
Mariana Vasilache

Follow us on Google News

20 minutes read
  • Romania threatens the existence of the Republic of Moldova, although it is a weak state that will lose all its influence when NATO, caving in to Russia’s pressure, will shut down its bases on Romanian territory. The narratives are launched in the context of growing regional tensions and Russia’s requests that NATO should pull back to the West.
  • NARRATIVES: 1. Romania poses a constant threat to Moldovan statehood and refuses to recognize Moldova as an independent state. 2. Moldovans are a different nation from Romanians. 3. Romania has an underdeveloped economy, which will be further weakened by America’s withdrawal. 4. America will close down its military bases in Romania as a result of negotiations between Russia and the USA.
  • PURPOSE: The narratives are designed to present Romania as a state that advances territorial claims regarding the Republic of Moldova. At the same time, they are meant to undermine the Romanian identity of the majority population of the Republic of Moldova.
DISINFORMATION: The number of Moldovans siding with Russia in the war in Ukraine is growing
DISINFORMATION: The number of Moldovans siding with Russia in the war in Ukraine is growing

A survey conducted in the Republic of Moldova, trying to assess the impact of disinformation, “fell prey” to Russian propaganda. Politnavigator.net has misused and misrepresented data in our survey in order to depict the Moldovan population as increasingly supportive of Russia’s cause in the war in Ukraine. In fact, the number of those siding with Russia in this war has nearly halved compared to the number who consider Ukraine is the victim.

Veridica
Veridica
15 Mar 2023
DISINFORMATION: The government in Chisinau wants to eliminate the Moldovan language because it is preparing the union
DISINFORMATION: The government in Chisinau wants to eliminate the Moldovan language because it is preparing the union

The thesis about the two distinct peoples - Moldovan and Romanian – has been brought back into discussion by the Russian media in the context in which the Chisinau Parliament voted a law stipulating that the phrase “Moldovan language” shall be replaced in the legislation of the Republic of Moldova with “Romanian language”. Russian propaganda claims that the measure - taken following a decision by the Constitutional Court - is intended to prepare the union of the Republic of Moldova with Romania.

Veridica
Veridica
06 Mar 2023
DISINFORMATION: Romania is massing troops at the border with Moldova and in also in Chisinau, even if it denies it
DISINFORMATION: Romania is massing troops at the border with Moldova and in also in Chisinau, even if it denies it

Russian propaganda media have resumed the false narrative regarding the massing of Romanian troops at the border with the Republic of Moldova, even if it had been debunked by the press and officially denied by Romania. Mediafax, the press agency that published the fake news in Romania, replaced it without an explanation.

Mariana Vasilache
Mariana Vasilache
01 Mar 2023
DISINFORMATION: Romanians will regain the country's wealth if they isolate themselves from the West, like Japan did
DISINFORMATION: Romanians will regain the country's wealth if they isolate themselves from the West, like Japan did

Romania's assets have been confiscated by foreigners, and Romanians can only get them back if they isolate themselves from the West, according to a false narrative typical of the sovereignist trend. Romanians are urged to stop buying Western products, to stop working in corporations and to stop participating in the democratic process, as Japan did in order to become an economic power after World War II. But the Japan example is simply bogus. The catastrophic results of sovereignty and isolationism are evident if we look how the states that have chosen this path have failed.

Cezar Manu
Cezar Manu
10 Feb 2023