Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube LinkedIn

DISINFORMATION: Inclusive and health policies are forms of totalitarianism

Disinformation

Vaccination, tolerance of LGBTQ+ people, digitalization – all these translate into the establishment of a totalitarian regime, according to a Russian historian who stands against vaccination and supports the theory that “ultra-globalists” want to control humanity through the pandemic. The narratives are part of a campaign aimed at undermining Western democracies by hijacking the values ​​that underlie them, such as democracy and freedom.  At the same time, it seeks to create confusion about the difference between political concepts and fundamental freedoms and health-care measures.

NEWS: “What is the difference between authoritarianism and totalitarianism? There is an important difference between authoritarianism and totalitarianism, the Soviet and Russian scientist, historian, social philosopher, sociologist, publicist, candidate in historical sciences, and director of the Center for Russian Studies at the Institute of Fundamental and Applied Research of the Humanitarian University of Moscow, Andrei Fursov, says, quoted by Noi.md. “Authoritarianism is when you are told what not do, by any means, while totalitarianism tells you what you must do. For example, you must treat LGBTQ+ people well, you must be happy that they exist, you must get vaccinated, you must jump into the digital world. This is totalitarianism”, he said.

Reality

NARRATIVE: Inclusive policies towards the LGBTQ + community, anti-Covid health policies, including vaccination, and the digitization process are a form of totalitarianism.

CONTEXT: For years, propaganda associated with the Kremlin, as well as ultra-conservative and far-right groups in Western states, have been attacking certain policies specific to liberal democracies, such as those relating to the LGBTQ + minority, migrants, etc., resorting including to concepts that form the foundation of those democracies. Thus, limiting the rights of the LGBTQ + minority or rejecting migrants are not presented as efforts to limit the freedoms and rights of those target groups, but as ways to defend the freedoms and rights of “normal” people, of the “traditional family”, of the “nation”, to protect Christian, spiritual and moral values. This type of argumentation and misuse of terminology has also been used for the pandemic-related narratives.

Against the background of restrictions imposed by the authorities to stop the wave of infections, demonstrations have taken place in several European countries, in which protesters denounced the restriction of fundamental freedoms and rights and tried to present sanitary measures, taken on the basis of expert recommendations and scientific data, as measures of a political nature. Often, such protests are animated by various leaders of extremist parties, personalities who stand against vaccination or the mandatory use of protective masks, promoters of nationalist messages, etc. Such dissatisfaction with the anti-Covid-19 vaccines has an even greater impact in the context in which the virus has developed new, more violent strains, the number of cases of infection in countries with low immunization rates is increasing, and the authorities in some states are considering compulsory vaccination of certain social categories and imposing restrictions on those who do not hold a Covid certificate.  Against this background, the antivaxxer trend has been going up, and more and more voices are talking about discrimination against those who do not want to be vaccinated. These narratives are circulating in parallel with the wave of fake news on a conspiracy note about the nature of the virus, the vaccine and a global cabal that is allegedly using them both.

The Russian historian Andrei Fursov has spoken in several interviews about the Covid pandemic, claiming that “ultra-globalists” want to control the evolution of humanity through “coronavirus hysteria”. Some of Covid's anti-vaccination and anti-vaccination theories have been debunked by  the Voxucraine.org  portal.

PURPOSE:  The narratives aim to associate Western democracies with totalitarian regimes, distort pro-vaccination or pro-LGBTQ+ messages, and create confusion about the difference between health or human rights measures and political concepts.

WHY THE NARRATIVES ARE FALSE: Totalitarianism is a political regime that applies the dictatorship of a person, a group of people, or a single party. Totalitarian ideology is opposed to the concept of open society, and the majority of the population is deprived of civil rights and freedoms. Fascism, Nazism and Communism were recognized as totalitarian regimes, which were based on violence and the repression of any form of freedom, the prohibition of a multi-party system, territorial expansion and, as the case may be, egalitarianism or racism. The party that holds a monopoly over the political life is based on an ideology, which becomes state norm. Also, in a totalitarian regime, the state has control over the law enforcement bodies, over the economy, the institutions and the media that represent its interests.

Tolerance towards minorities, including the sexual ones, and the protection of their rights seen as part of the fundamental human rights (practically it’s not about granting other rights, but the same rights that the majority has) comes in direct contradiction with the idea of ​​totalitarianism. Vaccination or digitalization, to which the author refers, are not even political concepts and are not characteristics of any kind of political regime. Health-care policies can be used by both totalitarian and democratic states (and in the totalitarian ones, if so decided, there is no possibility of challenging them - in China, for example, no one protested, as in the West, against large-scale vaccination or the draconian lockdown imposed by the authorities in certain situations).

Digitalization is a process of modernization, which facilitates work and development in all areas, has allowed access to information, streamlines various services and optimizes administrative processes, etc. And again, the totalitarian regimes are the ones that use modern communication tools in the interest of the state, to transmit certain messages or to monitor the population.

THE NARRATIVES BENEFIT: The Kremlin and the political forces that aim to gain supporters by promoting such narratives.

 

  • Publication / Media:
    noi.md
  • Date of publication:
    13/10/2021
  • Target audience:
    The anti-Western, anti-vaxxers, homophobes
  • Political affiliation:
    PSRM
  • Key narrative:
    Inclusive policies towards the LGBTQ + community, anti-Covid health policies, including vaccination, and the digitization process are a form of totalitarianism.
Mariana Vasilache

15 Oct 2021
Mariana Vasilache

Follow us on Google News

12 minutes read
  • Vaccination, tolerance of LGBTQ+ people, digitalization – all these translate into the establishment of a totalitarian regime, according to a Russian historian who stands against vaccination and supports the theory that “ultra-globalists” want to control humanity through the pandemic. The narratives are part of a campaign aimed at undermining Western democracies by hijacking the values that underlie them, such as democracy and freedom. At the same time, it seeks to create confusion about the difference between political concepts and fundamental freedoms and health-care measures.
  • For years, propaganda associated with the Kremlin, as well as ultra-conservative and far-right groups in Western states, have been attacking certain policies specific to liberal democracies, such as those relating to the LGBTQ + minority, migrants, etc., resorting including to concepts that form the foundation of those democracies. Thus, limiting the rights of the LGBTQ + minority or rejecting migrants are not presented as efforts to limit the freedoms and rights of those target groups, but as ways to defend the freedoms and rights of “normal” people, of the “traditional family”, of the “nation”, to protect Christian, spiritual and moral values. This type of argumentation and misuse of terminology has also been used for the pandemic-related narratives.
  • PURPOSE: The narratives aim to associate Western democracies with totalitarian regimes, distort pro-vaccination or pro-LGBTQ+ messages, and create confusion about the difference between health or human rights measures and political concepts.
DISINFORMATION: The pro-European government of Moldova is to blame for the increases in public transportation fees, introduced by the socialist mayor of Chișinău
DISINFORMATION: The pro-European government of Moldova is to blame for the increases in public transportation fees, introduced by the socialist mayor of Chișinău

The PAS government is responsible for the imminent increase in public transportation fees in Chișinău, because it allowed for an increase in fuel prices, Chișinău city hall councilman, Alexandr Odițov, has said. His statement was publicized by a number of news agencies controlled by the Socialists. In fact, fuel prices went up as a result of a global increase in energy prices.

Veridica
Veridica
16 May 2022
DISINFORMATION: Russia will be forced to resort to nuclear weapons
DISINFORMATION: Russia will be forced to resort to nuclear weapons

Putin has announced the start of World War III and will use nuclear weapons because, due to the West’s involvement, its forces cannot win the war. The narrative is promoted by Sorin Roșca Stănescu, who was given a criminal sentence and who is known for his opinions that very much resemble Russian propaganda. The Kremlin has long promoted the possible start of nuclear warfare, in order to determine the West to withdraw its support for Ukraine.

Mădălin Necșuțu
Mădălin Necșuțu
12 May 2022
DISINFORMATION: Moldova is renouncing its neutrality and is preparing to fight Russia
DISINFORMATION: Moldova is renouncing its neutrality and is preparing to fight Russia

The Government in Chișinău wants to renounce the neutrality status of the Republic of Moldova, while the West is providing this country with weapons to turn it into a living shield against Russia, the pro-Kremlin website politnavigator.net writes, reiterating narratives about Romania’s military presence in the Republic of Moldova and military support Moldova is allegedly providing to Ukraine.

Veridica
Veridica
09 May 2022
DISINFORMATION: Romanian troops, alongside Poland, Ukraine and Moldova, are preparing to invade Transnistria
DISINFORMATION: Romanian troops, alongside Poland, Ukraine and Moldova, are preparing to invade Transnistria

Romania, Poland, Ukraine and the Republic of Moldova will jointly attack the separatist region of Transnistria, according to disinformation narratives carried by the Romania media. The disinformation was published in Romania in a version that contains a number of false information, which is a typical example of Russian propaganda.

Mădălin Necșuțu
Mădălin Necșuțu
04 May 2022